# post_pr150_runtime_wiring_audit · Sub-spec 5/5 · Gemini X1 auto loop runtime path
- task: task-2685
- chair_authorization_id: CHAIR-AUTH-POST-PR150-RUNTIME-WIRING-AUDIT-20260526-JJONGS-AUDIT-001
- audit_mode: read-only
- audit_date: 2026-05-26 04:20 UTC
- main_repo_head: 2752182a
- references: PR #149 (8 commits X1 round 2-6 on `task/task-2662-dev2`) · PR #150 (3 commits X1 None safety on `task/task-2673-dev8`) · `anu_v3/` 44 files (untracked)

## 영역 5 결선 verdict (10 sub-steps)

| # | Sub-step | Verdict | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | fresh review 감지 | **FAIL** | `fresh_review` / `gemini_review_poll` / `detect_new_review` / `submitted_at` → 0 production hit on origin/main runtime path |
| 2 | unresolved 수집 | **PARTIAL** | `anu_v3/batch_hold_adjudicator.py:329` 주석 reference only · 활성 fetch 코드 0 |
| 3 | 6조건 자동 평가 | **PARTIAL** | `anu_v3/policy_profile_engine.py` condition schema only · 6-condition 평가기 0 |
| 4 | X1 자동수정 | **PARTIAL** | `anu_v3/auto_remediation_planner.py:75-76` **`PLAN_ONLY = True` · `DISPATCH_PERFORMED = False`** · `assert_plan_only()` L127-152 subprocess/os.system/git 호출 forbidden |
| 5 | regression | **FAIL** | post-fix pytest 자동 invocation 0 (batch_dependency_classifier.py 주석만) |
| 6 | commit/push | **FAIL** | auto remediation path에서 git commit/push 0 (assert_plan_only forbidden) |
| 7 | thread resolve | **FAIL** | `anu_v3/policy_profile_engine.py:319-321` gemini_thread_resolve config parse only · `resolveReviewThread` API call 0 |
| 8 | per-head nudge 1회 | **FAIL** | per_head / head_nudge / nudge_once / nudge_dedup 0건 |
| 9 | watcher 재부착 | **FAIL** | reattach / re_attach / watcher.*restart 0건 |
| 10 | terminal state만 회장 보고 | **PARTIAL** | `anu_v3/consolidated_summary_candidate_generator.py` 프레임워크 존재 · X1 loop 결선 0 |

## 결함 list

| ID | Severity | Path · line | 설명 |
|---|---|---|---|
| D5.framework | **CRITICAL** | `/home/jay/workspace/anu_v3/` 44 files | 전체 untracked (git status). origin/main · 모든 PR branch 0. batch mtime 2026-05-23 20:10 동일 → 일괄 생성 후 미커밋. |
| D5.4 | **CRITICAL** | `anu_v3/auto_remediation_planner.py:76,77,127-152` | `PLAN_ONLY = True` · `DISPATCH_PERFORMED = False` · `assert_plan_only()` static validator subprocess/os.system/git 호출 explicitly forbidden. 실제 자동수정 dispatch 0. |
| D5.1 | **CRITICAL** | 미구현 | fresh review polling loop 0. X1 loop 진입점 자체 미존재. |
| D5.2 | **CRITICAL** | 미구현 | unresolved threads 수집 코드 0. 자동 fix 대상 식별 불가. |
| D5.5 | HIGH | 미구현 | post-fix regression 자동 invocation 0. plan에 명시되어도 실행 미연결. |
| D5.6 | HIGH | assert_plan_only forbidden | auto commit/push 차단됨. plan-only doctrine과 X1 closed loop 충돌. |
| D5.7 | HIGH | `anu_v3/policy_profile_engine.py:319` | thread resolve config parse만. Gemini API 호출 0. |
| D5.8 | MEDIUM | 미구현 | per-head nudge dedup 0. 중복 X1 round 위험. |
| D5.9 | MEDIUM | 미구현 | watcher re-attach 0. 자동수정 후 추적 단절. |
| D5.10 | MEDIUM | 미통합 | terminal state framework 존재 · X1 loop 결선 0. |

## 결선 status summary

| 영역 | wired | notes |
|---|---|---|
| 1-10 sub-steps wired | **0 / 10** | 전부 PARTIAL or FAIL |
| anu_v3 framework | untracked | git status untracked · 44 files |
| 실측 X1 round 코드 (PR #149, #150) | PR branch only · main 미머지 | 8f7c56c6 / afb37bd3 외 task/task-2662-dev2 · task/task-2673-dev8 |
| dispatch 가능 코드 | 0 | PLAN_ONLY=True · DISPATCH_PERFORMED=False |

## 종합 verdict

**FAIL (0/10 runtime wiring)** — Gemini X1 auto loop runtime path origin/main 결선 0%. anu_v3/ 44 파일은 untracked preparatory architecture · auto_remediation_planner는 PLAN_ONLY doctrine. PR #149/#150 X1 round commit들은 각자 worktree branch only.

## 권고 (★ 별도 task + chair signature)

1. anu_v3/ 44 files commit 정책 결정 (chair 승인 후 PR 단위 분할 머지)
2. PLAN_ONLY doctrine vs X1 closed loop 충돌 해소 (별도 dispatch layer 신설 vs PLAN_ONLY 해제)
3. fresh review polling loop entry point 신설 (scripts/x1_loop_runner.sh 또는 anu_v3/x1_runtime.py)
4. Gemini API resolveReviewThread 결선
5. per-head nudge dedup + watcher re-attach 결선
6. 10 sub-step regression suite (각 단계 PASS 강제)