# post_pr150_runtime_wiring_audit · 통합 packet · 260526
- task: task-2685 — POST_PR150_RUNTIME_WIRING_AUDIT (Track 3 · read-only)
- chair_authorization_id: CHAIR-AUTH-POST-PR150-RUNTIME-WIRING-AUDIT-20260526-JJONGS-AUDIT-001
- audit_mode: ★ read-only audit only · 코드 0 · runtime 변경 0
- audit_date: 2026-05-26 04:20 UTC
- auditor: 헤르메스 (dev1-team)
- main_repo_head_actual: **2752182a** (task-2661 Phase 2b · 2026-05-25 · "callback normal fire delay → absolute timestamp" PR #148)
- main_repo_head_claimed_in_task_md: **319170b95b1330c3e9554eca88973e68f60e93e9** (★ `git cat-file 319170b9` → fatal: Not a valid object name · NON-EXISTENT)
- forbidden_action_count: 0 (코드 수정 0 · commit 0 · push 0 · PR 0 · merge 0 · runtime 0 · live settings.json 0 · hooks live 0 · dispatch.py 0)
- file_overlap_with_task_2662_2684: 0 (★ 본 audit prefix `post_pr150_runtime_wiring_audit_*` 차별화)

## 0. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY (★ 가장 중요)

**task-2685 task md의 audit 전제 자체가 false였음.** 회장이 명시한 `PR #150 MERGED commit 319170b9...`는 repo에 존재하지 않는 SHA. 실제 origin/main HEAD는 2752182a (task-2661 Phase 2b)이고, PR #150 X1 commits (8f7c56c6 / 522a1174 / 0aa96e1b)는 `task/task-2673-dev8` worktree branch에만 존재하며 origin/main에 머지되지 않았음. task-2680 self-key hardening fix (commit 814491f0)도 worktree only — origin/main 미머지.

5 영역 audit 결과:
- **영역 1 (PR watcher classifier)**: FAIL (worktree only · production import 0)
- **영역 2 (task-2680 self-key hardening main 반영)**: FAIL (main 미반영 · 6 수정 목표 worktree only)
- **영역 3 (finish-task.sh callback runner)**: PARTIAL (5/6 PASS · callback FAIL silent swallow 1 결함)
- **영역 4 (stale watcher result 무시 로직)**: FAIL (미구현 · marker · target_head 비교 0)
- **영역 5 (X1 auto loop runtime path)**: FAIL (0/10 sub-step wired · PLAN_ONLY doctrine · anu_v3/ 44 files untracked)

**main repo의 PR watcher / self-key hardening / X1 auto loop 결선 status: 거의 0%.** 회장 verbatim의 "PR #150 MERGED" 전제가 무너지면서 audit 대상 자체가 무 worktree-only architecture로 판명. 결함 fix는 별도 task + chair signature 강제.

## 1. 5 체크 영역 verdict (회장 verbatim 5)

| # | 영역 | Verdict | 핵심 evidence | 결함 sev | sub-spec |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | PR watcher terminal classifier 결선 | **FAIL** | `utils/pr_watcher_terminal_state_classifier.py` origin/main 미존재 · worktree task-2673-dev8 only · production import 0 | CRITICAL × 2, HIGH × 2 | [post_pr150_runtime_wiring_audit_pr_watcher_classifier_260526.md] |
| 2 | task-2680 self-key hardening main 반영 | **FAIL** | task-2680 commit 814491f0 origin/main 0 · 9 files +2535/-1 worktree only | CRITICAL × 1, HIGH × 4, MEDIUM × 1 | [post_pr150_runtime_wiring_audit_self_key_hardening_260526.md] |
| 3 | finish-task.sh callback runner 결선 | **PARTIAL (5/6 PASS)** | runner invoke + ANU key + absolute timestamp + envelope guard + fallback 분리 PASS · callback FAIL silent swallow (L1378 `\|\| echo`) FAIL | MEDIUM-HIGH × 1 | [post_pr150_runtime_wiring_audit_finish_task_callback_260526.md] |
| 4 | stale watcher result 무시 로직 | **FAIL** | target_head vs latest_head 비교 0 · STALE_WATCHER_RESULT_IGNORED marker 0 · anu_v2 인프라는 layer mismatch | HIGH × 3, MEDIUM × 2 | [post_pr150_runtime_wiring_audit_stale_watcher_logic_260526.md] |
| 5 | Gemini X1 auto loop runtime path | **FAIL (0/10)** | anu_v3/ 44 files untracked · auto_remediation_planner PLAN_ONLY=True · DISPATCH_PERFORMED=False · fresh review polling 0 | CRITICAL × 4, HIGH × 3, MEDIUM × 3 | [post_pr150_runtime_wiring_audit_x1_auto_loop_260526.md] |

전체 verdict: **FAIL (4) · PARTIAL (1) · PASS (0)**

## 2. 결선 결함 list (path · line · severity)

### CRITICAL

| ID | Path · line | 설명 |
|---|---|---|
| C1 | task-2685.md L10 vs `git cat-file 319170b9` | task md 주장 PR #150 머지 SHA가 repo에 0. audit 전제 false. |
| C2 | origin/main vs `.worktrees/task-2673-dev8/utils/pr_watcher_terminal_state_classifier.py` (399 lines) | PR #150 origin/main 미머지. 분류기 production 결선 0. |
| C3 | origin/main vs `.worktrees/task-2680-dev2/` 9 files (+2535 lines) | task-2680 self-key hardening 6 수정 목표 전부 main 미반영. self-key callback 사고 재발 위험 active. |
| C4 | `/home/jay/workspace/anu_v3/` 44 files | git status untracked. 모든 PR branch 0. batch mtime 2026-05-23 20:10. |
| C5 | `anu_v3/auto_remediation_planner.py:76-77,127-152` | PLAN_ONLY=True · DISPATCH_PERFORMED=False · assert_plan_only subprocess/os.system/git forbidden. X1 closed loop 차단됨. |
| C6 | X1 loop fresh review polling entry point | 미구현. X1 loop 진입점 자체 0. |
| C7 | X1 loop unresolved threads 수집 | 미구현. 자동 fix 대상 식별 불가. |

### HIGH

| ID | Path · line | 설명 |
|---|---|---|
| H1 | scripts/** dispatch/** utils/** | classifier production import 0건 (test 4건만) |
| H2 | `.worktrees/task-2673-dev8/utils/pr_watcher_terminal_state_classifier.py:298-377` register_terminal_callback | design only · production caller 0 |
| H3 | origin/main `dispatch/normal_fallback_callback_helper.py` argv post-check gate | task-2680 L237 미반영 시 self-key callback bypass 가능 |
| H4 | origin/main NON_AUTHORITATIVE_SELF_COLLECTOR 분류 | 0 · self-key 사고 chair escalation 미작동 |
| H5 | origin/main `build_anu_independent_reverify_request` | worktree only · reverify 자동 dispatch 0 |
| H6 | watcher runner target_head vs latest_head 비교 | 미구현 (영역 4) |
| H7 | PR merged 시 watcher 결과 auto-stale 분류 (watcher scope) | 미구현 (anu_v2 replacement scope만 존재) |
| H8 | stale result discard guard | 미구현 |
| H9 | post-fix regression auto invocation | 미구현 (영역 5) |
| H10 | auto commit/push X1 closed loop | assert_plan_only forbidden (영역 5) |
| H11 | Gemini resolveReviewThread API call | 0 (config parse만 · 영역 5) |

### MEDIUM

| ID | Path · line | 설명 |
|---|---|---|
| M1 | `scripts/finish-task.sh:1378-1380` | callback helper exit 2 → `\|\| echo` silent. fail-stop 위반. design intent vs requirement 충돌. |
| M2 | task-2685.md L45 STALE_WATCHER_RESULT_IGNORED | requirement만 · code/spec 0 |
| M3 | `anu_v2/gemini_stale_prevention_runner.py` | watcher terminal state scope 미wired (replacement PR scope만) |
| M4 | per-head nudge dedup (영역 5) | 미구현 |
| M5 | watcher 재부착 (영역 5) | 미구현 |
| M6 | terminal state framework | anu_v3 framework 존재 · X1 loop 결선 0 |
| M7 | self-key 사고 schedule_history backfill | NON_AUTHORITATIVE classification marker 0 (Track A 78F385CF · Track J 33E60E8B) |

## 3. task-2680 main 반영 evidence (★ 회장 verbatim 보고 필수 3)

```
$ cd /home/jay/workspace
$ git log origin/main --grep="2680" --oneline
(empty)

$ git log origin/main --oneline | head -3
2752182a task-2661 Phase 2b — callback normal fire delay → absolute timestamp (PR #148 squash)
0e172435 Merge pull request #144 from Jeon-Jonghyuk/task/task-2641-anu-restack
bd286a61 task-2641: Gemini HIGH auto-remediation — line-by-line streaming + full audit scan

$ git for-each-ref --sort=-committerdate refs/heads/ refs/remotes/ \
    --format='%(committerdate:short) %(refname:short) %(objectname:short)' | head -10
2026-05-26 task/task-2662-dev2 afb37bd3
2026-05-26 origin/task/task-2662-dev2 afb37bd3
2026-05-26 task/task-2673-dev8 8f7c56c6        ← ★ PR #150 X1 head
2026-05-26 origin/task/task-2673-dev8 8f7c56c6
2026-05-26 task/task-2680-dev2 814491f0        ← ★ task-2680 self-key hardening
2026-05-26 origin/task/task-2680-dev2 814491f0
2026-05-26 task/task-2676-dev5 d67eac70
2026-05-25 task-2683-dev3-watcher 2752182a
2026-05-25 task/task-2664-dev4 2752182a
2026-05-25 origin/main 2752182a

$ git diff --stat origin/main task/task-2680-dev2 | tail -10
 dispatch/normal_fallback_callback_helper.py        |  68 ++
 memory/reports/task-2680.md                        | 137 ++++
 memory/specs/...callback_authority_4source_verify_doctrine_260526.md | 113 ++++
 memory/tasks/task-2680.md                          | 177 +++++
 tests/callback_authority_4source/__init__.py       |   0
 .../test_4source_validator.py                      | 735 +++++++++++++++++++++
 utils/anu_callback_registrar.py                    |  44 +-
 utils/callback_authority_4source_validator.py      | 572 ++++++++++++++++
 utils/callback_collector_helper_integration.py     | 690 +++++++++++++++++++
 9 files changed, 2535 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-)
```

결론: task-2680 commit **814491f0** origin/main 0건 — `task/task-2680-dev2` branch only. 9 files · +2535/-1 lines worktree에만 존재. self-key hardening main 반영 = **FAIL**.

## 4. stale watcher 무시 로직 evidence (★ 보고 필수 4)

```
$ git grep -n "target_head\|target_sha\|stale_head\|head_drift\|latest_head" origin/main -- '*.py'
(no matches)

$ git grep -n "STALE_WATCHER_RESULT_IGNORED" origin/main
(no matches)
$ grep -rn "STALE_WATCHER_RESULT_IGNORED" /home/jay/workspace/.worktrees/task-2673-dev8/
(no matches)
$ grep -rn "STALE_WATCHER_RESULT_IGNORED" /home/jay/workspace/.worktrees/task-2680-dev2/
(no matches)

$ git ls-tree -r origin/main --name-only | grep stale
anu_v2/fixtures/gemini_stale_on_head_2556.json
anu_v2/fixtures/stale_prevention_*.json (5 files)
anu_v2/gemini_stale_prevention_runner.py
anu_v2/tests/test_gemini_stale_prevention_runner_2545.py
... (모두 replacement PR scope · watcher terminal state scope 아님)
```

결론: stale watcher result 무시 로직 origin/main 미구현. STALE_WATCHER_RESULT_IGNORED marker는 task md L45 요구만 존재. 인접 인프라(anu_v2 stale_prevention)는 다른 layer scope.

## 5. Gemini X1 auto loop runtime path evidence (★ 보고 필수 5)

```
$ cd /home/jay/workspace
$ git status anu_v3/
(전체 untracked · 44 files)

$ grep -n "PLAN_ONLY\|DISPATCH_PERFORMED" anu_v3/auto_remediation_planner.py
75:PLAN_ONLY = True
76:DISPATCH_PERFORMED = False
127:def assert_plan_only(...):
128:    """subprocess/os.system/git 호출 explicitly forbidden"""
...
152:    raise PlanOnlyViolation(...)

$ git log --all --oneline --grep="X1\|x1_auto\|x1_remediation" | head -10
afb37bd3 fix(anu-v3.1): X1 round 6 REPEATED_DISAGREEMENT 일관성 (PR #149 threads N/O/P/Q)
8f7c56c6 fix(pr-watcher): X1 round 3 None safety hardening for Gemini high/medium threads L/M (PR #150)
... (모두 task/task-2662-dev2 또는 task/task-2673-dev8 branch only)

$ git branch --contains 8f7c56c6
+ task/task-2673-dev8
$ git branch --contains afb37bd3
+ task/task-2662-dev2
```

implementation status:
- 10 sub-step wired: **0/10**
- anu_v3/ 44 files: untracked
- PR #149/#150 X1 commits: branch only · main 미머지
- dispatch 가능 코드: 0 (PLAN_ONLY doctrine)

gap list: fresh review polling · unresolved 수집 · 6조건 평가기 · X1 dispatch · regression invoke · auto commit/push · thread resolve API · per-head nudge dedup · watcher reattach · terminal state 결선 — 10/10 미구현 or PLAN_ONLY 차단.

## 6. file overlap (★ task-2662~2684 0)

본 audit 산출물 prefix: `post_pr150_runtime_wiring_audit_*`
- 6 specs (1 packet + 5 sub) · 모두 신규 파일명 · task-2662~2684 specs와 중복 0
- events: `task-2685.done` · `task-2685.post-pr150-runtime-wiring-audit-result-260526.json` · 모두 신규
- report: `memory/reports/task-2685.md` · 신규

확인:
```
$ ls /home/jay/workspace/memory/specs/post_pr150* | head -10
(직전 Write 완료 5 sub-spec + 본 packet — 모두 신규)

$ ls /home/jay/workspace/memory/specs/ | grep -E "2662|2663|2664|...|2684" | grep -v post_pr150
(기존 파일들과 prefix 다름 · 중복 0)
```

**file_overlap_count: 0**

## 7. forbidden_action_count (target 0)

| 금지 동작 | count | 비고 |
|---|---|---|
| 코드 수정 (utils/** scripts/** dispatch/**) | 0 | read-only 분석만 |
| commit | 0 | git commit 0 |
| push | 0 | git push 0 |
| PR 생성 | 0 | gh pr create 0 |
| merge | 0 | gh pr merge 0 |
| runtime 변경 | 0 | live process 0 |
| live settings.json 변경 | 0 | .claude/** 미접근 |
| hooks live 변경 | 0 | hooks/** 미수정 |
| dispatch.py 변경 | 0 | 미수정 |
| Axis runtime · HARNESS_ENFORCED 전체 선언 · BLOCK 확대 · policy 승격 | 0 | 미수행 |

**forbidden_action_count: 0**

## 8. recommended next action (★ 별도 task + chair signature 강제)

### Track A (CRITICAL · 즉시)
1. **task-2680 main 머지 PR 신규** — chair signature 필수. 9 files +2535/-1 lines. self-key hardening 6 수정 목표 main 반영.
2. **PR #150 (task-2673-dev8) main 머지 PR 신규** — chair signature. PR watcher classifier + 4 regression tests main 반영.
3. **task md L10 PR #150 머지 SHA 정정** — `319170b9...` 비존재 · 정정 + 회장 재발급 verbatim 필요.

### Track B (HIGH · Track A 머지 후)
4. **watcher runner classifier 결선 task** — PR #150 머지 후 watcher runner 1곳에서 `classify()` + `register_terminal_callback()` 호출. (별도 task + chair signature)
5. **finish-task.sh L1378 fail-stop 결정 task** — chair 판정 필요 · 비차단 설계 vs fail-stop requirement 충돌. design intent 보존 시 audit checklist 보정.
6. **stale watcher result ignore logic 구현 task** — target_head 박제 + latest_head 비교 + STALE_WATCHER_RESULT_IGNORED marker + 3 regression. (별도 task + chair signature)
7. **anu_v3/ 44 files commit 정책 task** — chair 승인 후 PR 단위 분할 머지. PLAN_ONLY doctrine vs X1 closed loop 충돌 해소.

### Track C (MEDIUM)
8. **schedule_history backfill task** — 미배포 gap 기간 self-key 사고 NON_AUTHORITATIVE classification 회고 분류.
9. **per-head nudge dedup + watcher reattach 구현 task** — X1 loop 결선 후속.

### 종합
**현 시점 (origin/main HEAD 2752182a) PR watcher · self-key hardening · X1 auto loop · stale watcher 4개 모두 production 결선 0~partial.** 회장 verbatim 의 "PR #150 MERGED" 가정이 무너지면서 후속 결선 점검이 무의미. **회장 재검토 + 머지 강제 + chair signature × 4 별도 task 권고.**

## 9. ANCHOR 준수 검증

- ANCHOR-1 (read-only audit only · 코드 0 · runtime 0): ✅ forbidden_action_count = 0
- ANCHOR-2 (5 체크 영역 모두 verdict + evidence · 결함 fix 별도 task + chair signature): ✅ 5 영역 verdict + evidence 인용 + 별도 task 권고
- ANCHOR-3 (main repo HEAD 319170b9 기준): ⚠️ 319170b9 미존재 → 실제 HEAD 2752182a로 audit · worktree-only 산출물 별도 표기
- ANCHOR-4 (task-2662~2684 파일 변경 0 · `post_pr150_runtime_wiring_audit_*` 차별화): ✅ file_overlap_count = 0

## 종결

성공 상태: **POST_PR150_RUNTIME_WIRING_AUDIT_READY**

(★ ANU normal callback 별도 등록 · helper · ANU key c119085addb0f8b7 · envelope ≤3900 bytes · absolute timestamp now+30s)