# task-2684 — PR_149_AFB37BD3_CI_GEMINI_WATCH 결과 보고서

- 담당: **dev4 비슈누** (★ read-only watcher · 코드 0 · merge 0 · nudge 0)
- chair_authorization_id: `CHAIR-AUTH-PR149-AFB37BD3-CI-GEMINI-WATCH-20260526-JJONGS-WATCH-001`
- 작성: 2026-05-26 04:14 KST

## 1. terminal_state

**`HOLD_FOR_CHAIR`**

성공 토큰: `PR_149_AFB37BD3_CI_GEMINI_WATCH_TERMINAL_STATE_REPORTED`

## 2. 보고 11 필드

| 필드 | 값 |
|---|---|
| terminal_state | HOLD_FOR_CHAIR |
| PR 번호 | 149 |
| head SHA | afb37bd3616339a6468d940cdd417e331a51b36c |
| CI 11 | 11/11 SUCCESS |
| gemini-review-gate | SUCCESS |
| phase3-merge-gate | SUCCESS |
| Gemini head match afb37bd3 | true |
| unresolved count | 3 (Gemini fresh on afb37bd3) |
| mergeStateStatus | BEHIND |
| forbidden_action_count | 0 |
| recommended next action | Chair adjudication on 3 Gemini findings + branch update authorization |

## 3. 폴링 로그 (총 6회, 약 11.6분)

- Poll #1 (04:01:58 KST): CI 2 green, 8 queued, lock-in-check IN_PROGRESS. unresolved=3, mergeStateStatus=BEHIND.
- Poll #2 (04:04:52): CI 5 green (lock-in-check, hidden-path-audit 추가 SUCCESS). 6 queued. BEHIND.
- Poll #3 (04:06:54): CI 8 green (merge-safety, gemini-review-gate, phase3-merge-gate SUCCESS). guard IN_PROGRESS. BEHIND.
- Poll #4 (04:09:11): CI 10 green. qc-check IN_PROGRESS. BEHIND.
- Poll #5 (04:11:08): **CI 11/11 SUCCESS**. BEHIND. reviewDecision="".
- Poll #6 (04:13:36, 안정 확인): 상태 동일. unresolved=3 지속.

## 4. 종합 판정 근거

- ✅ CI 11/11 SUCCESS (gemini-review-gate · phase3-merge-gate 포함)
- ⚠ Gemini fresh unresolved 3건 (commit afb37bd3, createdAt 19:02:16-17 UTC, ~12분 경과 후에도 해결 없음)
  - 1건 security-medium 추정 / 2건 medium 추정
- ⚠ mergeStateStatus=BEHIND (branch task/task-2662-dev2 가 main 보다 뒤짐)
- ⚠ reviewDecision="" (사람 승인 없음)
- ⓘ task md 조기 HOLD 트리거(unresolved>0 + Gemini fresh + BLOCKED) 중 BLOCKED 미충족 → 즉시 HOLD 대신 정상 폴 완료 후 수렴 판정으로 HOLD_FOR_CHAIR 분류.

merge 가능 경로는 회장 승인 후 ① Gemini 코멘트 해결/dismiss → ② branch 업데이트(rebase 또는 main merge) → ③ reviewDecision APPROVED 순.

## 5. 격리 / 허용·금지 준수

- PR #150 (merged) 결과 혼입 0 — head afb37bd3 만 평가.
- 코드 수정 0 / PR merge 0 / auto-merge 0 / 추가 Gemini nudge 0 / dev bot re-dispatch 0 / Axis runtime 미접근 / dispatch.py 미접근 / live settings.json 미접근.
- 사용 명령: `gh pr view`, `gh api graphql`, `python3 -c`, `cokacdir --currenttime` 만 사용.

## 6. expected_files 3 생성

- `memory/events/task-2684.pr-149-afb37bd3-ci-gemini-watch-result-260526.json` ✓
- `memory/events/task-2684.done` ✓ (touch)
- `memory/reports/task-2684.md` ✓ (본 문서)

## 7. ANU normal callback

- envelope: `memory/events/anu_callback/task-2684-normal-completion.json`
- absolute fire timestamp: now+30s (cokacdir --cron --at "YYYY-MM-DD HH:MM:SS")
- ANU key: `c119085addb0f8b7` · self-key 0 · UTF-8 ≤ 3900 bytes · envelope only

## 8. 다음 액션 권고 (Chair)

1. Gemini 3건 unresolved 코멘트 검토 (afb37bd3 코드 라인 단위) → accept-and-remediate 또는 dismiss-as-acceptable 결정.
2. branch task/task-2662-dev2 의 main 동기화 권한 부여 (rebase vs merge main).
3. 사람 승인 (reviewDecision APPROVED) 후 merge 진행 또는 추가 X1 round 지시.

끝 — `PR_149_AFB37BD3_CI_GEMINI_WATCH_TERMINAL_STATE_REPORTED`