# task-2682 — PR_149_23A357E6_CI_GEMINI_WATCH_TERMINAL_STATE_REPORTED

- **terminal_state**: `HOLD_FOR_CHAIR`
- **chair_authorization_id**: `CHAIR-AUTH-PR149-23A357E6-CI-GEMINI-WATCH-20260526-JJONGS-WATCH-001`
- **watcher**: dev1 헤르메스 (auto X1 loop step 11)
- **observed_at_kst**: 2026-05-26 03:24:41

## 11 보고 필드

| # | 항목 | 값 |
|---|------|-----|
| 1 | terminal state | `HOLD_FOR_CHAIR` |
| 2 | PR 번호 | #149 |
| 3 | head SHA | `23a357e6944b6d1024e22136794e4b7c26e244a7` |
| 4 | CI 11 checks | 11/11 SUCCESS (cancel-kill-switch · taskctl-state-guard x2 · qc-check · hidden-path-audit · lock-in-check · merge-safety-check · gemini-review-gate · phase3-merge-gate · ci/guard · guard) |
| 5 | gemini-review-gate | SUCCESS |
| 6 | phase3-merge-gate | SUCCESS |
| 7 | latest Gemini head match 23a357e6 | ✓ match (review PRR_kwDORcJVSM8AAAABA8V61w · 2026-05-25T18:22:37Z · COMMENTED) |
| 8 | unresolved count | 4 (모두 head 23a357e6 · high=3 medium=1) |
| 9 | mergeStateStatus | `BLOCKED` (mergeable=MERGEABLE) |
| 10 | forbidden_action_count | **0** |
| 11 | recommended next action | 회장 판단 대기. dev2 round 6 코드 수정 dispatch 또는 unresolved 4건 comment-only 처리 결정 |

## ★ 조기 HOLD_FOR_CHAIR 전환 근거

task md 규칙 verbatim:
> `poll #N unresolved>0 + Gemini fresh + BLOCKED → HOLD_FOR_CHAIR 조기 전환`

poll #1 에서 3 조건 모두 충족 → 30 poll/60min 대기 없이 즉시 전환:

- unresolved>0 ✓ (4건 모두 head 23a357e6)
- Gemini fresh ✓ (head 23a357e6 review at 2026-05-25T18:22:37Z)
- BLOCKED ✓ (mergeStateStatus=BLOCKED)

## Unresolved 4 thread 요약 (모두 gemini-code-assist · head 23a357e6)

| thread_id | priority | 주제 |
|-----------|----------|------|
| PRRT_kwDORcJVSM6EmuG_ | high | schemas의 `triggered_gates` `minItems: 1` 제약 — REPEATED_DISAGREEMENT 미트리거 시 packet 생성 실패 |
| PRRT_kwDORcJVSM6EmuHP | high | `_build_hold_packet` 함수 — triggered_gates 비어 있을 때 dummy 처리 로직 결함 |
| PRRT_kwDORcJVSM6EmuHV | high | safety gate 미트리거 + 수렴 실패 케이스에서 dummy critical_7 강제 삽입 |
| PRRT_kwDORcJVSM6EmuHX | medium | REPEATED_DISAGREEMENT 시 critical_7 오삽입 — non-safety hold 명확화 필요 |

## PR_150 격리

★ PR #149 head 23a357e6 단일 평가. PR #150 결과 혼합 0건.

## 허용 8 사용 / 금지 10 회피

- 사용: `gh pr view 149` (read-only) · `gh api graphql reviewThreads` (read-only) · expected_files 3개 write
- 회피: 코드 수정 0 · PR merge 0 · auto-merge 0 · 추가 Gemini nudge 0 · dev bot 재dispatch 0 · expected_files 외 write 0 · Axis runtime 0 · dispatch.py 0 · live settings.json 0 · HARNESS_ENFORCED 위반 0

## 권고 next action

회장 결정 대기:

1. **옵션 A (코드 수정)**: dev2에게 round 6 dispatch — `schemas/anu_codex_micro_refinement_*.json` 의 `triggered_gates.minItems` 0 또는 oneOf 분기 적용 + `utils/anu_codex_micro_refinement_loop.py::_build_hold_packet` 의 dummy critical_7 삽입 제거
2. **옵션 B (acknowledge merge)**: Gemini 4 unresolved를 comment-only 인정 후 merge 진행 (Gemini는 NONE association · advisory)

## 종결

성공: `PR_149_23A357E6_CI_GEMINI_WATCH_TERMINAL_STATE_REPORTED`