# task-2553 — FINAL CLOSEOUT consolidated summary

> Track 1 (task-2553+50) · executor: dev5-team 마르둑 (key 109fa85250c6d46b) 1회 한정
> read-only 종합 · 기존 +32~+49 산출물·frozen anchor·policy_profile_engine byte-0 consume
> hold_for_chair: **false** · §6 HOLD 트리거 전수 non-operative — read-only 종합, ANU-Codex loop 자동 수렴, 회장 보고 불요(consolidated only)

## 불변식
- git HEAD `20456b5f83fc039f2fd6f50f4b94095c29b41bfb` · branch `task/task-2553p1-f1-clean-replacement` (expected match: True)
- frozen anchor 6모듈 byte-0 all EQUAL: **True**
- consumed upstream 산출물 전수 present: **True**
- 기존 산출물 무수정 · merge/write/dispatch/cron 0 · expected_files allowlist 한정 · Track2/3 DISJOINT

## §2.1 완료된 구조적 보장

```json
{
  "title": "완료된 구조적 보장",
  "items": [
    {
      "ref": "+32",
      "guarantee": "executor completion callback MANDATORY rule 코드 강제 복원 — inject_completion_callback_clause(다음 prompt 자동) + validate_spec(누락 FAIL/HOLD) + validate_4tuple(normal_collector_cron_id 필수) + validate_closeout_evidence. NO-CRON≠callback 금지 정정 코드화. regression 20 PASS.",
      "status": "DONE"
    },
    {
      "ref": "+44_46",
      "guarantee": "durable 4-tuple append-only registry(memory/events/callback_4tuple_index.jsonl, registry-first classify, NO_LEDGER→fail-safe DEFER) + canonical artifact root resolver(/home/jay/workspace hardcoded, read-only). 1회성 cron 자동삭제 후에도 durable. regression 34 PASS.",
      "status": "DONE"
    },
    {
      "ref": "+47",
      "guarantee": "registry write-back(verified normal-collector identity 바인딩, append-only·idempotent, naive mark_completed stale copy 결함 회피, callback mandatory 무약화) + event-trigger(registry COMPLETED → NEXT_ACTION_READY, 고정시각/dead-man 진행트리거 금지=FORBIDDEN_TRIGGER_SOURCE, proposal-only). regression 16 PASS.",
      "status": "DONE"
    },
    {
      "ref": "+49(AUTHORITATIVE)",
      "guarantee": "executor self-callback/self-collector/self-adjudication/self-dispatch 실 runtime 구조적 차단 — callback_owner_validator + self_collector_guard + authoritative_verdict_selector + writeback_binding_conflict_guard 가 dispatch.core/dispatch.py/prompt(ADDITIVE re-export) + cron_dispatch_guard 에 결선. mismatch 시 CallbackRegistrationBlocked raise. 다음 dispatch 부터 executor self-collector 구조적 불가. regression 합계 164 PASS.",
      "status": "DONE"
    },
    {
      "ref": "frozen",
      "guarantee": "frozen anchor 6모듈 byte-0 전 체인 보존(callback_4tuple_registry 774d5506… · executor_completion_contract 364caa11… · callback_event_trigger 352ad0f5… · anu_delegation 83b3e307… · policy_profile_engine 2363e291… · parallel_batch_coordinator 10529421…). git HEAD/branch 전 체인 EQUAL(commit/push/merge 0).",
      "status": "DONE"
    }
  ]
}
```

## §2.2 독립 ANU 검증 완료 항목 (authoritative PASS)

```json
{
  "title": "독립 ANU 검증 완료 항목 (authoritative PASS)",
  "items": [
    {
      "ref": "+44_46",
      "verdict": "PASS (collector authoritative — executor draft supersede). 독립 단일 Codex audit 3 HIGH(fail-open 마스킹) → ANU 사후 adjudication MEDIUM non-blocking 강등(§3.C acceptance 충족·spec-relevant 경로 regression 10/11/12 차단) + MANDATORY follow-up(tri-state 경화).",
      "supersedes_executor_draft": true
    },
    {
      "ref": "+47",
      "verdict": "PASS (collector-authoritative supersede executor draft). Codex round-1 3 HIGH → F1/F2 BY-DESIGN HIGH→LOW 강등, F3 VALID→REMEDIATED(REG_SHA 리터럴 핀). round-2 AUDIT CLEAN.",
      "supersedes_executor_draft": true
    },
    {
      "ref": "+48",
      "verdict": "PASS (collector-authoritative). Codex round-1 2 HIGH(F1 모호 multi-fallback / F2 normal_success_unchanged 하드코딩) → 양건 VALID→REMEDIATE → round-2 AUDIT CLEAN.",
      "supersedes_executor_draft": true
    },
    {
      "ref": "+49",
      "verdict": "AUTHORITATIVE_PASS. executor(dev2 오딘) self-Codex/self-adjudication/self-collector/self-dispatch 0(코드 강제). Codex audit·adjudication·회수·독립검증·후속 = 독립 ANU collector 세션. authoritative_verdict_selector 가 self-chain QUARANTINED·independent ANU verdict 만 authoritative 로 코드화.",
      "supersedes_executor_draft": true
    }
  ],
  "registry_durable_success_completed_tasks": [
    "task-2553+44_46",
    "task-2553+47",
    "task-2553+48"
  ]
}
```

## §2.3 live observation 만 남은 항목

```json
{
  "title": "live observation 만 남은 항목",
  "items": [
    {
      "ref": "+41",
      "remaining": "cancel-on-success 6-step read-only passive observation harness — mock/fixture 한정(FakeCronLister/SpyRemover/SpyScheduleHistory). 실 cron/4-tuple/schedule_history/발화 0. Codex infra-unavailable(ChatGPT account 'model not supported') = 미수행이며 미해소 finding 0(HOLD 아님), 수동 self-audit clean.",
      "tier": "mock_only"
    },
    {
      "ref": "+48",
      "remaining": "cancel-on-success live remove e2e — properly-bound 4-tuple, operational=True real-mode seam + 실제 cron-remove 호출이나 전용 격리 FakeCronWorld/WorldSpyRemover. real_ops_cron_force_delete_count=0. fallback_fired_count=0 end-to-end·normal_success_unchanged=true 입증. 진성 production live(실 운영 fallback cron 제거) tier 는 미수행(Layer A NO-CRON 설계상).",
      "tier": "isolated_e2e"
    },
    {
      "ref": "+47",
      "remaining": "event-trigger next_action = proposal-only(authority=none). 실 dispatch enact 는 authorized ANU 세션 한정 — +48 entry(event-driven, 독립 ANU collector 가 dev1 Hermes 위임 실행)로 1회 관측됨. 후속 dispatch 의 실 운영 관측은 누적 pilot 대상.",
      "tier": "proposal_then_event_driven"
    }
  ],
  "true_production_live_status": "NOT_PERFORMED (by Layer A NO-CRON design; operational pilot 후보 C2)"
}
```

## §2.4 다음 operational pilot 후보

```json
{
  "title": "다음 operational pilot 후보",
  "candidates": [
    {
      "id": "C-PILOT-1",
      "candidate": "policy profile engine operational seam — task_2553_final_closeout profile(Track3 병렬 landed, read-only 관측 PRESENT) 등록 후 본 goal_type engine-auto-resolve 운영 활성화.",
      "blocked_by": "Track3 mapping 운영 승격 결정(profile 자체는 PRESENT)",
      "priority": "HIGH"
    },
    {
      "id": "C-PILOT-2",
      "candidate": "cancel-on-success live remove 를 실(비격리) 운영 normal-success 사이클에서 1회 관측. 현재 isolated/e2e 입증만.",
      "blocked_by": "별도 회장 GO(실 운영 cron 접촉)",
      "priority": "MEDIUM"
    },
    {
      "id": "C-PILOT-3",
      "candidate": "+44_46 tri-state probe 경화(seen/not_seen/indeterminate; indeterminate→RESULT_MISSING 금지) operational rollout.",
      "blocked_by": "별도 회장 GO(+45 scope 흡수 가능)",
      "priority": "HIGH"
    },
    {
      "id": "C-PILOT-4",
      "candidate": "registry write-back lifecycle 를 상시 normal-callback collector 기본 경로로 승격(현 +47 dogfood 입증).",
      "blocked_by": "운영 승격 결정",
      "priority": "MEDIUM"
    },
    {
      "id": "C-PILOT-5",
      "candidate": "authoritative_verdict_selector + callback_owner_validator 를 N회 실 dispatch 누적 관측(executor-self 구조적 거부 입증). 이미 결선됨 — pilot=관측.",
      "blocked_by": "누적 실 dispatch 발생",
      "priority": "MEDIUM"
    }
  ]
}
```

## §2.5 더 이상 반복하지 않아도 되는 임시/중복 doctrine

```json
{
  "title": "더 이상 반복하지 않아도 되는 임시/중복 doctrine",
  "items": [
    {
      "doctrine": "NO-CRON 이 executor completion callback 을 금지한다는 오독",
      "disposition": "+32 코드 강제 + normal-callback-mandatory-doctrine-correction 으로 영구 정정. 재론 불요.",
      "enforced_by_code": true
    },
    {
      "doctrine": "executor self-collector 가 수용 가능할 수 있다",
      "disposition": "+49 구조적 불가능화. selfcollector-violation-containment-decision 의 수동 강제 반복 불요(코드 강제).",
      "enforced_by_code": true
    },
    {
      "doctrine": "fixed-time/dead-man 은 진행 트리거가 아니다(반복 수동 명시)",
      "disposition": "+47 event-trigger FORBIDDEN_TRIGGER_SOURCE + regression 으로 코드화. doctrine 반복 불요.",
      "enforced_by_code": true
    },
    {
      "doctrine": "executor draft 자가보고 'ANU-Codex 수렴' 신뢰",
      "disposition": "+44_46/+47/+48/+49 mandatory 독립 collector audit 가 supersede(executor draft=frozen evidence 보존). 자가보고 투명성-gap 구조적 해소.",
      "enforced_by_code": true
    },
    {
      "doctrine": "narrow vs authoritative 산출 재adjudication(+45 narrow, 구 narrow +49 dev6)",
      "disposition": "narrow 무손실 보존 + authoritative supersede 로 settled. 반복 adjudication 불요.",
      "enforced_by_code": false
    }
  ]
}
```

## §2.6 남은 LOW/backlog 후보

```json
{
  "title": "남은 LOW/backlog 후보",
  "items": [
    {
      "id": "BL-1",
      "ref": "+44_46",
      "item": "tri-state probe 경화(3 probe seen/not_seen/indeterminate; indeterminate 시 RESULT_MISSING 금지)",
      "severity": "MEDIUM(non-blocking)",
      "status": "OPEN",
      "mandatory_followup": true
    },
    {
      "id": "BL-2",
      "ref": "+47",
      "item": "F1/F2 idempotency key scope BY-DESIGN HIGH→LOW 강등 — spec 변경 없으면 무조치, LOW 추적",
      "severity": "LOW",
      "status": "TRACKED_NO_ACTION"
    },
    {
      "id": "BL-3",
      "ref": "+32",
      "item": "Pyright reportMissingImports + importlib ModuleSpec|None typing — config-only false-positive(runtime 해소)",
      "severity": "LOW(cosmetic)",
      "status": "TRACKED_NO_ACTION"
    },
    {
      "id": "BL-4",
      "ref": "+41",
      "item": "Codex infra-unavailable(ChatGPT account) — infra 가용 시 +41 harness Codex audit 재실행(수동 self-audit 이미 clean)",
      "severity": "LOW",
      "status": "OPEN_WHEN_INFRA"
    },
    {
      "id": "BL-5",
      "ref": "policy-engine",
      "item": "task_2553_final_closeout profile — 병렬 Track3 가 landed(read-only 관측 PRESENT). engine-auto-resolve 운영 승격 잔여.",
      "severity": "LOW(dependency)",
      "status": "OBSERVED_RESOLVED_BY_TRACK3"
    }
  ]
}
```

## §2.7 self-chain QUARANTINED vs independent ANU authoritative PASS 구분

```json
{
  "title": "self-chain QUARANTINED vs independent ANU authoritative PASS 구분",
  "self_chain": {
    "definition": "executor self key 발사 / executor==collector / self-adjudication / self-dispatch",
    "disposition": "authoritative_verdict_selector → QUARANTINED·영구 비권위. independent_anu_count=0 → verdict=FAIL·classification=AUTHORITATIVE_VERDICT_PENDING (self-chain 만으로 PASS 확정 금지).",
    "spoof_handling": "claimed_origin=independent_anu 위장 self-session 도 owner identity 로 QUARANTINED."
  },
  "independent_anu": {
    "definition": "owner key c119085addb0f8b7 · role=ANU · executor≠collector · 4-tuple valid",
    "disposition": "owner_is_independent_anu=True → 그 verdict authoritative. PASS→AUTHORITATIVE_PASS.",
    "precedence": "independent FAIL > HOLD > self-chain PASS (fail-closed)"
  },
  "chain_application": "+44_46/+47/+48/+49 전부 독립 ANU collector 세션 authoritative PASS(executor draft frozen evidence 보존·supersede). 구 narrow +49(dev6 페룬) self/test-중심 → dev2 오딘 authoritative(독립) supersede, narrow 무손실 보존."
}
```

## §2.8 cancel-on-success mock / isolated / live observation 구분

```json
{
  "title": "cancel-on-success mock / isolated / live observation 구분",
  "mock": {
    "ref": "+41",
    "scope": "FakeCronLister/SpyRemover/SpyScheduleHistory passive 6-step observation. 실 cron 0.",
    "evidence": "regression 19 PASS, install_isolation_guards self-test 3 PASS"
  },
  "mock_isolated_audit": {
    "ref": "+37",
    "scope": "wired entrypoint cancel-audit — 격리 FakeCronLister/SpyRemover, spy_remover_calls=[{FB37-0001,dry_run:false}], 실 운영 cron 삭제 0",
    "evidence": "regression 19 PASS"
  },
  "isolated_e2e": {
    "ref": "+48",
    "scope": "properly-bound 4-tuple, operational=True real-mode seam 1회 + 실제 cron-remove(WorldSpyRemover.calls=[{PB48FALLBACK,dry_run:false}]) 전용 격리 FakeCronWorld. real_ops_cron_force_delete_count=0. fallback_fired_count=0 e2e·normal_success_unchanged=true. 보수 가드 무회귀(mismatch/missing→보존, remove 실패→decouple).",
    "evidence": "regression 163 PASS, E2E_PASS"
  },
  "live": {
    "status": "NOT_PERFORMED",
    "reason": "Layer A NO-CRON 설계 — 실 운영 fallback cron 제거 0(회장 §5). operational pilot 후보 C-PILOT-2, 별도 회장 GO 필요."
  }
}
```

## §2.9 policy profile engine operational seam 완료 범위

```json
{
  "title": "policy profile engine operational seam 완료 범위",
  "completed_scope": {
    "engine_module": "anu_v3/policy_profile_engine.py",
    "engine_byte0_frozen": true,
    "engine_role": "PURE CONTRACT DERIVER (status ∈ {RESOLVED, HOLD_FOR_CHAIR})",
    "dispatch_selection_seam": "anu_v3/dispatch_profile_selection.py (+38, additive, read-only consume)",
    "coordinator_binding_seam": "anu_v3/coordinator_profile_binding.py (+39, file-level contract, zero import coupling)",
    "historical_case_instances": [
      "goal_type_profile_mapping.json",
      "policy_profile_default_dispatch_adoption.json",
      "runtime_structure_smoke_pilot.json",
      "task-2553+40.clean_replacement_pr_merge.json",
      "task-2553+40.post_merge_smoke_artifact_closeout.json",
      "task-2553+40.review_thread_cleanup.json",
      "task-2553+40.test_only_hardening_pr_merge.json",
      "task_2553_final_closeout.json",
      "test_only_hardening_pr_merge_v1.json"
    ],
    "historical_dry_run_match": "+40 4/4 contract-level fidelity, engine byte-0",
    "task_2553_final_closeout_profile_present": true,
    "task_2553_final_closeout_profile_owner": "Track3 (mapping 신설 — 본 Track1 범위 외)",
    "task_2553_final_closeout_profile_observation": "OBSERVED_PRESENT — 병렬 Track3 가 read-only 관측 시점 이미 landed (Track1 무관·무변·read-only 관측만)",
    "engine_auto_resolve_eligibility": "task_2553_final_closeout profile PRESENT(Track3 병렬 landed, read-only 관측) → 본 goal_type engine-auto-resolve 등록 가능 (pilot readiness 기록)",
    "track1_disjoint_note": "Track1 은 policy_profiles 에 write 0 — 디렉터리 목록 read-only 관측만. Track3 산출물 무수정(§4 Track2/3 DISJOINT 준수)."
  },
  "in_scope_done": [
    "C1 engine(+33) byte-0 정본 — PURE CONTRACT DERIVER",
    "+38 dispatch_profile_selection seam (engine read-only consume → dispatch selection binding, fail-closed, DISPATCH_LIFECYCLE_EFFECT=none)",
    "+39 coordinator_profile_binding (file-level contract, auto-confirm hard-pinned False, zero import coupling)",
    "+40 4 historical case 인스턴스화 + dry-run contract-level fidelity 4/4"
  ],
  "not_in_scope_yet": [
    "task_2553_final_closeout profile mapping (Track3 — 본 Track1 범위 외)",
    "engine-auto-resolve of this goal_type (Track3 완료 후 등록 가능)",
    "engine 의 write/merge 권한 (영구 금지 — engine 은 deriver, write surface 0)"
  ]
}
```

## §6 HOLD 평가

```json
{
  "hold_for_chair": false,
  "triggers": {
    "critical7": false,
    "codex_unresolved_high_critical": false,
    "credential_permission_expansion": false,
    "expected_files_overlap_track23": false,
    "forbidden_target_touch": false,
    "self_callback_collector_adjudication_dispatch": false,
    "callback_owner_not_anu_key": false,
    "authoritative_selector_bypassed": false,
    "fallback_deadman_as_progress_trigger": false,
    "fixedtime_gate_as_progress_trigger": false,
    "registry_checkpoint_escalated_primary": false,
    "profile_engine_write_merge_required": false,
    "existing_artifact_mutation_required": false,
    "goal_unachievable": false,
    "frozen_byte0_broken": false,
    "consumed_artifact_missing": false,
    "git_branch_drift": false
  },
  "verdict": "§6 HOLD 트리거 전수 non-operative — read-only 종합, ANU-Codex loop 자동 수렴, 회장 보고 불요(consolidated only)"
}
```

## callback (a)

완료 직후 normal completion callback cron 을 **독립 ANU key `c119085addb0f8b7`(chat 6937032012)로만** 발사. executor self key `109fa85250c6d46b` 절대 미발사(+49 코드 강제 정본). 회수·검증·Codex audit·adjudication·batch coordinator 통합은 그 독립 ANU collector 세션. ANU fallback=ANU key·안전망 한정·진행 트리거 아님.