merged_by: app/jeon-jonghyuk-taskctl-bot

names: taskctl-state-guard guard cancel-kill-switch qc-check hidden-path-audit phase3-merge-gate ci/guard lock-in-check gemini-review-gate merge-safety-check taskctl-state-guard

value: PASS

kind: primary

kind: secondary

value: completed

path: status

value: done

impact_scanner: PASS

ci_preflight: PASS

l1_smoketest: PASS

goal_assertions: PASS

unresolved_gate: PASS

post_merge_lag_explanation: task-timers end_time (11:53:11Z) - mergedAt (11:48:30Z) = 4m41s of post-merge finish-task.sh execution covering smoke + reconcile phases

4413661a: Merge origin/main into task/task-2537-dev4 (BEHIND resolution)

cf01d5c1: Gemini 2nd high 2 auto-accepted (BOT identity env + refs/ real bug fix inside expected_files)

verdict: clean

task_2544_dispatch_status: READY_TO_DISPATCH (boycott marker may be released, fixture must include this WARN→PASS evidence backfill case)


user_facing_issue_resolved: 기록탭 5/8 5/9 + 신호등 미반영 main 반영 완료

expected_mergedBy: app/jeon-jonghyuk-taskctl-bot

actual_mergedBy: JonghyukJeon

root_cause: schedule 환경에 BOT_GITHUB_TOKEN 미설정 → default GH_TOKEN fallback merge

remediation_required_in_followup_task: BOT_GITHUB_TOKEN 없는 환경 merge 시도 전 fail-fast

lifecycle_state: FINALIZED

essence_smoke_verdict: PASS

remediation_required_in_followup_task: post_merge_smoke_runner: task md smoke_command 부재 시 task type별 default smoke profile lookup

remediation_required_in_followup_task: default profile도 없으면 EVIDENCE_INCOMPLETE / SMOKE_COMMAND_UNDEFINED 별도 분류 (Critical #7 직결 X)

remediation_required_in_followup_task: SMOKE_COMMAND_UNDEFINED ↔ Critical #7 매핑 정책은 후속 task에서 결정

decision: MERGED_WITH_DIVERGENCES — body PASS, main reflection complete, 2 divergences pinned for followup task issuance


decision: REPLACEMENT_PR_MERGED — task-2544+1 본질 PASS, PR #89 보존 유지, scope expansion 사고 복구 완료


defect_kind: task state file 부재로 finish-task.sh GIT-GATE 차단

essence_separation: 본 결함은 task-2544+1 본질(replacement PR clean diff)과 혼합 금지 — task md amendment 0

remediation_required_in_followup_task: lifecycle/state bootstrap 보강: task md 발행 시 .tasks/state/<task_id>.json 자동 생성

remediation_required_in_followup_task: finish-task.sh GIT-GATE: state 파일 부재 시 명확한 분류 (BOOTSTRAP_REQUIRED 등) + 자동 생성 또는 fail-fast

remediation_required_in_followup_task: task_id에 '+' suffix 포함 시 정규화 처리 (정규식 `^task-[\d._]+(\+\d+)?$` 허용)