merge_state: BLOCKED

ci: 9 PASS / 2 FAIL (gemini-review-gate, phase3-merge-gate)

trigger_actor: jeon-jonghyuk-taskctl-bot[bot]

note: bot-authored /gemini review ineffective. PR #74 (task-2523) — bot identity (jeon-jonghyuk-taskctl-bot[bot])이 /gemini review 코멘트 게시했으나 Gemini 미응답 10분. 인간 trigger 또는 Gemini Code Assist auto-review 설정 필요.


resolution_actor: chair

decision_text: A안 — chair posts /gemini review on PR #75 once. Bot 9~12 steps proceed automatically.


commit_push_pr: complete

pr_author: app/jeon-jonghyuk-taskctl-bot

block_reason: gemini_app_webhook_unresponsive_16min+ / gemini-review-gate evidence_count=0 / phase3-merge-gate evidence_count=0

bot_failed_attempts:
/gemini review comment
close+reopen
empty commit 277c7b14

resume_finalize_when_gemini_evidence_arrives:
fetch origin/main
merge origin/main (NOT rebase)
CI/Gemini recheck
auto_gemini_triage if review thread
CI 11/11
mergeStateStatus CLEAN
HEAD SHA lock
BOT_GITHUB_TOKEN squash merge
smoke
reconcile apply

if_evidence_zero_persists: OPEN_BLOCKED_BY_GEMINI_EXTERNAL_SERVICE / no chair report unless state change

followup_hardening: Gemini gate event-driven redesign priority UP — distinguish 5 cases (webhook unresponsive / evidence_count=0 / bot slash ineffective / human trigger required / quota/timeout/service outage) + fallback decision


chair_decision_summary: PR #76 monitor cadence — 60min polling chain 중단, event-driven 재확인으로 전환

1_pr_76_classification: EXTERNAL_GATE_BLOCKED / OPEN_BLOCKED stuck PR (개별 PR 한정, 전역 장애 아님)

verdict: global webhook outage 가설 폐기 — per-PR 개별 stuck

this_cron_role: one_shot_termination_enshrinement_only — no further cron registration permitted


investigator: dev1-team_hermes_solo + vulcan_research + argos_pr_analysis

automation_verdict: IMPOSSIBLE

automation_reason: pull_request.opened only / synchronize-reopened-labeled-check-workflow_run all unsubscribed / bot comment author filter (sender.type==User + OWNER/MEMBER/COLLABORATOR association)

task_2538_recommendation: conditional_finalize_hold_release_post_approval_check (gemini reviews 7 rounds completed)

pr_86_distinct_root_cause: gemini-review-gate_workflow_git_exit_code_128 (separate from BEHIND/Gemini gap, range out, follow-up task pending)

evidence_anchor: gemini-dispatch.yml (run-gemini-cli official example)


behind_window: NONE (clean throughout)

taskctl_bot_response: NONE (bot-to-bot suppression confirmed)

result: MERGED


gemini_review_gate_conclusion: failure

gemini_review_gate_annotation: git exit code 128

distinct_root_cause_hypothesis: gemini-review-gate_workflow_git_exit_128 (NOT BEHIND, NOT trigger filter)

best_effort_speculation: BEHIND transition timing window overlap with Gemini processing window OR transient service blip


counter_evidence_against_behind_filter: PR open trigger fired despite branch BEHIND state

final_state: BLOCKED (approval missing, NOT BEHIND/Gemini gap)

finalize_recommendation: conditional_release_post_approval_check (gemini gap not the blocker)


root_cause_hypothesis: 새 dev4 claude session이 cokacdir 16:30 restart 후 자동 재발사되어 task-2537 PR #86 OPEN_HOLD 상태 인지 X / finalize 14단계 자체 진입 시도 / Gemini gap에서 60초×25분 polling pattern 학습 자체 발사

systemic_fix_required: task-2542 root cause 보고서 결과 + dev4 task-2537 worktree에 'finalize boycott marker' 박제 필요 (재발사 차단)


bot: vishnu

owner_trigger_login: JonghyukJeon

gemini_review_state: COMMENTED

gemini_thread_priority: medium

merge_state_status: BEHIND

mergeable: MERGEABLE

chairman_directive_summary: finalize-boycott 해제 승인. BOT finalize 14-step 재개. 진행 1~10번 + 금지 9항 + 완료조건 9항