{ "schema_version": "anu_v2.replacement_lineage.v1", "original_pr": 92, "original_task": "task-2545", "original_head": "15cf6ad011e184ca298996d47253501152700287", "replacement_task": "task-2545+1", "replacement_reason": "REPLACEMENT_REQUIRED_BY_SELF_POLICY", "self_policy_module": "GEMINI_STALE_PREVENTION_RUNNER", "self_policy_rule": "same_pr_push_forbidden_for_code_changing_fix_after_fresh_gemini_evidence", "evidence_summary": { "gemini_review_id": 4259466790, "code_changing_count": 3, "style_only_count": 1, "high_priority_lines": [ 245 ], "medium_priority_lines": [ 723, 735, 760 ] }, "dispatch_status_history": [ { "stage": "PRE_DISPATCH_FAIL_FAST", "outcome": "ESCALATED", "blocker": "BOT_GITHUB_TOKEN_MISSING", "blocker_source_rule": "task-2545+1.dev5-replacement-prompt.txt §7-6 (BOT_GITHUB_TOKEN fail-fast)", "preserved_pr_92": { "state": "OPEN", "head": "15cf6ad011e184ca298996d47253501152700287", "head_unchanged": true, "close_reopen": false, "force_push": false, "rebase": false, "empty_commit": false, "additional_commits": 0 }, "ts": "2026-05-10T16:20:04.470016+00:00" }, { "stage": "REPLACEMENT_DISPATCH_RETRY", "outcome": "ESCALATED", "ts": "2026-05-10T16:29:40.851140+00:00", "retry_index": 1, "completed_at": "2026-05-10T16:51:54.941802+00:00", "pr_number": 93, "pr_url": "https://github.com/Jeon-Jonghyuk/dev_workspace/pull/93", "pr_head_commit": "5ad46d999988b4272ecc954add28e9b542dd286e", "ci_pass_count": 9, "ci_total": 11, "ci_failed_checks": [ "gemini-review-gate", "phase3-merge-gate" ], "blocker": "GEMINI_AUTO_REVIEW_NOT_TRIGGERED_FOR_BOT_OPENED_PR", "blocker_root_cause": "Gemini auto-review only triggers for chair-opened PRs. Bot-opened PR #93 receives no auto-review. PR #91 (task-2539+1 replacement) precedent: chair manually posted '/gemini review' at 2026-05-10T15:05:21Z to trigger review. §7-7 forbids bot /gemini review (신규 발사) — this prevents the bot from self-triggering. Replacement PR can't progress to merge without chair manually posting /gemini review on PR #93.", "blocker_source_rule": "v2 prompt §7-7 (bot /gemini review 신규 발사 금지) + structural human-in-the-loop dependency", "preserved_pr_92": { "state": "OPEN", "head": "15cf6ad011e184ca298996d47253501152700287", "head_unchanged": true, "close_reopen": false, "force_push": false, "rebase": false, "empty_commit": false, "additional_commits": 0 }, "replacement_pr_state": { "number": 93, "state": "OPEN", "head": "5ad46d999988b4272ecc954add28e9b542dd286e", "branch": "task/task-2545+1-dev5-replacement", "mergeable": "MERGEABLE", "mergeStateStatus": "BLOCKED", "ci_success": [ "cancel-kill-switch", "taskctl-state-guard", "qc-check", "hidden-path-audit", "lock-in-check", "merge-safety-check", "ci/guard", "guard" ], "ci_failed_for_human_loop": [ "gemini-review-gate", "phase3-merge-gate" ], "gemini_reviews_count": 0, "expected_chair_action": "post comment '/gemini review' on PR #93 to trigger Gemini fresh review" }, "critical_kind_canonical": "REPLACEMENT_PR_ALSO_FAILED", "critical_kind_canonical_index": 6, "critical_subtype": "GEMINI_AUTO_REVIEW_NOT_TRIGGERED_FOR_BOT_OPENED_PR_HUMAN_LOOP_REQUIRED", "bot_gemini_review_used": false, "force_rebase_used": false, "owner_pat_admin_override": false, "empty_commit_used": false, "audit_evidence_only_no_code_change_after_pr_open": true } ], "retry_reason": "BOT_GITHUB_TOKEN_MISSING_FOR_REPLACEMENT_PR_DISPATCH", "dispatch_status": { "stage": "REPLACEMENT_PR_FINALIZE_RESUME_AFTER_OWNER_GEMINI_TRIGGER", "outcome": "ESCALATED", "ts": "2026-05-10T19:02:30.934416+00:00", "retry_index": 2, "owner_gemini_trigger_completed": true, "owner_gemini_trigger_ack_evidence": { "gemini_review_id": 4259772138, "gemini_review_user": "gemini-code-assist[bot]", "gemini_review_state": "COMMENTED", "gemini_review_submitted_at": "2026-05-10T18:55:32Z", "gemini_review_commit_id": "5ad46d999988b4272ecc954add28e9b542dd286e", "pr_93_head": "5ad46d999988b4272ecc954add28e9b542dd286e", "evidence_freshness": "FRESH (commit_id == head)", "unresolved_threads_count_initial": 1, "unresolved_thread_id": "PRRT_kwDORcJVSM6A7CjN", "unresolved_thread_classification": "STYLE_ONLY_PERFORMANCE_LOOP_FUSION_NO_CORRECTNESS_BUG", "unresolved_thread_action": "REPLY_AND_RESOLVE_NO_CODE_CHANGE", "unresolved_threads_count_after_resolve": 0 }, "blocker_primary": "EFFECTIVE_DIFF_CONTRACT_VIOLATION", "blocker_root_cause": "task-2545+1 contract specifies expected_files=1 (anu_v2/gemini_stale_prevention_runner.py) but actual PR #93 diff contains 7 added files (runner.py + 5 stale_prevention_*.json fixtures + test_gemini_stale_prevention_runner_2545.py). The contract was framed assuming task-2545 PR #92 scaffolding had been merged to origin/main, but PR #92 is OPEN/ESCALATED unchanged. Therefore task-2545+1 replacement PR had to create the entire module from scratch, including tests and fixtures listed under task-2545+1 forbidden_paths. Resume prompt §명시 forbids expected_files amendment AND forbids push/force/rebase/close-reopen — automatic finalize is structurally blocked by this contract framing inconsistency.", "blocker_secondary": [ { "kind": "FORBIDDEN_PATH_IN_DIFF", "path": "anu_v2/tests/test_gemini_stale_prevention_runner_2545.py", "status": "added", "additions": 666, "task_md_intent": "regression rerun only, modification 0", "actual_state": "file does not exist on origin/main; replacement PR creates it" }, { "kind": "CI_STALE_PRE_OWNER_TRIGGER", "checks_failed": [ "gemini-review-gate", "phase3-merge-gate" ], "checks_completed_at": "2026-05-10T16:39:38Z/16:39:39Z", "owner_trigger_at": "2026-05-10T18:55:32Z", "lag_hours": 2.27, "rerun_attempted": false, "rerun_skipped_reason": "even if CI passes after rerun, §6 contract violation alone forces ESCALATED — rerun would not unblock" }, { "kind": "MERGE_STATE_BLOCKED", "merge_state_status": "BLOCKED", "mergeable": "MERGEABLE", "block_reason": "required status checks (gemini-review-gate, phase3-merge-gate) FAILURE" } ], "critical_kind_canonical": "REPLACEMENT_PR_ALSO_FAILED", "critical_kind_canonical_index": 6, "critical_subtype": "REPLACEMENT_PR_CONTRACT_FRAMING_INCONSISTENT_WITH_ORIGIN_MAIN_STATE", "section_8_finalize_status": { "§0_token_refresh": "PASS (BOT_GITHUB_TOKEN refreshed, expires 2026-05-10T19:56:36Z)", "§1_gemini_fresh_review": "PASS (review id 4259772138 at 2026-05-10T18:55:32Z)", "§2_evidence_commit_id_eq_head": "PASS (5ad46d999988b4272ecc954add28e9b542dd286e)", "§3_unresolved_threads": "PASS (1 thread classified STYLE_ONLY, replied + resolved, final count 0)", "§4_ci_all_success": "FAIL (2/11 FAILURE: gemini-review-gate, phase3-merge-gate)", "§5_merge_state_clean": "FAIL (BLOCKED)", "§6_effective_diff_eq_1": "FAIL (7 files vs 1 expected)", "§7_forbidden_paths_zero": "FAIL (test_gemini_stale_prevention_runner_2545.py present)", "§8_bot_identity": "PASS (BOT_GITHUB_TOKEN authenticates as installation; /user 403 expected for App tokens)", "§9_bot_squash_merge": "SKIP (blocked by §4-§7)", "§10_post_merge_smoke": "SKIP", "§11_lifecycle_reconciliation": "SKIP", "§12_done_acked_merge_done": "SKIP", "§13_dispatch_status_history": "EXECUTED (this entry)", "§14_pr_92_head_unchanged": "PASS (state=OPEN, head=15cf6ad011e184ca298996d47253501152700287)" }, "preserved_pr_92": { "state": "OPEN", "head": "15cf6ad011e184ca298996d47253501152700287", "head_unchanged": true, "close_reopen": false, "force_push": false, "rebase": false, "empty_commit": false, "additional_commits": 0 }, "preserved_pr_93": { "state": "OPEN", "head": "5ad46d999988b4272ecc954add28e9b542dd286e", "head_unchanged": true, "close_reopen": false, "force_push": false, "rebase": false, "empty_commit": false, "additional_commits_after_owner_trigger": 0 }, "forbidden_13_observed": { "additional_gemini_review_request": false, "bot_gemini_review_new_fire": false, "empty_commit": false, "close_reopen": false, "force_push_or_rebase": false, "pr_92_modification": false, "additional_commit_on_pr_93": false, "owner_pat_used": false, "default_gh_token_fallback_merge": false, "expected_files_amendment": false, "other_pr_or_task_mixed_in": false, "long_polling_or_self_register_loop": false, "md_report_only_pass_processing": false }, "decision": "OWNER_REVIEWS_CONTRACT_INCONSISTENCY_DECIDES_PR93_DIRECT_ADMIN_MERGE_OR_TASK_2545_PLUS_2_REFRAMING", "audit_evidence_only_no_code_change_after_pr_open": true } }