{ "marker_version": "v1", "marker_type": "pr_153_closed_preserved_scope_leak_and_callback_failure", "recorded_at": "2026-05-26T15:54:00+09:00", "recorded_by": "ANU_chair_facing_session", "source_attribution": "RECEIVED_INBOUND_THIS_SESSION (★ chair verbatim Option A close 결정)", "chair_directive_origin": "회장 verbatim 2026-05-26 — 'Option A를 선택한다. PR #153은 close한다. 단, 증거 보존을 위해 삭제하지 말고 preserve marker를 남겨라.'", "final_status_chair_verbatim": "PR_153_CLOSED_PRESERVED_SCOPE_LEAK_AND_CALLBACK_FAILURE", "pr_153_close_evidence": { "pr_number": 153, "pr_url": "https://github.com/Jeon-Jonghyuk/dev_workspace/pull/153", "title": "[task-2691] finish-task latency Phase 1: helpers + task_mode (Phase 2 scripts hook 위임)", "head_branch": "task/task-2691-dev8", "head_sha": "7065c3aea4866fadf9250cc94600235f03a669c7", "closed_at_utc": "2026-05-26T06:53:57Z", "closed_at_kst": "2026-05-26T15:53:57+09:00", "state": "CLOSED", "branch_preserved": true, "branch_delete_forbidden": "★ 증거 보존 의무" }, "chair_acknowledged_violations_8": [ "PR #153 changedFiles 42 (★ scope-diff.txt 16 file vs 26 file scope leak)", "expected_files 밖 26 file 유입", "PR #152 와 overlap 2 file: dispatch/__init__.py / scripts/finish-task.sh", "scripts/finish-task.sh 는 task-2691 Phase 1 수정 금지였음 (★ ANCHOR-1 + 금지 1번 위반)", "PR #153 mergeStateStatus DIRTY / CONFLICTING", "normal callback envelope 존재 but cron 등록 0 (★ NORMAL_CALLBACK_NOT_REGISTERED 변종 재발)", "finish-task 지연 개선 Phase 1 dogfood 실패 (★ envelope 3 SID dogfood 는 PASS · cron 발사 dogfood 는 FAIL)", "memory/plans/tasks/task-2568+2569 + cleanup scripts + git hooks 유입" ], "scope_leak_26_file_categorization": { "pr_152_overlap_2": [ "dispatch/__init__.py", "scripts/finish-task.sh" ], "task_2568_2569_plans_3": [ "memory/plans/tasks/task-2568/checklist.md", "memory/plans/tasks/task-2568/context-notes.md", "memory/plans/tasks/task-2568/plan.md" ], "task_2569_plans_3": [ "memory/plans/tasks/task-2569/checklist.md", "memory/plans/tasks/task-2569/context-notes.md", "memory/plans/tasks/task-2569/plan.md" ], "reports_3": [ "memory/reports/task-2568.md", "memory/reports/task-2569.md", "memory/reports/task-2569+1.md" ], "specs_3": [ "memory/specs/protection-list.json", "memory/specs/protection-list.md", "memory/task-timer.py", "memory/tasks/task-2569.md" ], "cleanup_scripts_4": [ "scripts/cleanup-stale-tasks.sh", "scripts/cleanup-workspace.py", "scripts/file_cleanup.py", "scripts/task_scope.py" ], "git_hooks_2": [ "scripts/git-hooks/pre-push", "scripts/pre_push_guard.py" ], "task_2569_regression_5": [ "tests/regression/test_cleanup_workspace_protection_2569.py", "tests/regression/test_dispatch_smoke_2569_plus_1.py", "tests/regression/test_finish_task_stash_lifecycle_2569.py", "tests/regression/test_scope_guard_lock_sha_2569.py", "tests/regression/test_task_md_preservation_2569.py" ] }, "scope_leak_root_cause_anu_analysis": { "primary": "dev8 라 봇이 main workspace 의 dirty state (★ task-2691.merge-blocked-by-main-workspace-state.json 의 7 non_task_files) 를 worktree 로 끌어옴", "secondary": "봇 self-evaluation 실패: scope-diff.txt 16 file 작성 but 실제 commit 42 file (★ self 검증 누락)", "tertiary": "finish-task.sh pre_push_guard blocked 상태에서도 commit 강행 후 push (★ 가드 우회)" }, "callback_failure_root_cause_anu_analysis": { "primary": "envelope 파일 작성 후 cokacdir --cron 호출 0 (★ schedule_history F99C1C91.log 흔적 0)", "irony": "★ task-2691 자체가 callback session propagation wiring fix Phase 1 → dogfood 자체 실패", "consistent_with_doctrine": "[[feedback_normal_callback_not_registered_variant_260523]] 박제 사고 재발 (★ envelope sendfile only / cron 등록 0)" }, "chair_verbatim_forbidden_9": [ "PR #153 merge", "PR #153 force push", "PR #153 cleanup rewrite", "PR #153 scope leak 파일 일부만 되돌려서 계속 사용", "PR #152 와 수동 병합", "scripts/finish-task.sh 수정", "live settings.json 변경 / hooks live 변경 / dispatch.py 변경", "Axis runtime 변경", "HARNESS_ENFORCED 전체 선언" ], "followup_task_2691_plus_a_status": { "decision": "task-2691+a 새 발의 (★ fresh origin/main 기준 별도 worktree)", "task_md_drafted": "memory/tasks/task-2691+a.md (★ ANU 작성 진행 · chair_authorization_id 회장 verbatim 발급 대기)", "dispatch_status": "HELD (★ chair_authorization_id 회장 verbatim 도착 후만 dispatch · 본 ANU 자기 정정 doctrine 적용)" }, "track_status_5": { "track_a_pr_149_x1_r7": "task-2689 watcher in progress (★ 5762AA9D · 별도 트랙)", "track_b_pr_151_self_key_hardening": "READ_ONLY_HOLD 유지", "track_c_task_2686_plus_1": "PR #152 HOLD_FOR_CHAIR (★ unresolved 6건 별도 판단 · PR #153 사고와 혼합 금지)", "track_d_pr_152_watcher": "task-2690 in progress", "track_e_finish_task_latency": "PR #153 CLOSED + task-2691+a 발의 준비 (★ chair_authorization_id 발급 대기)" }, "anu_action_count_session_aggregate": { "code_change": 0, "new_dispatch_cumulative": 5, "pr_closed": 1, "marker_written": 7, "git_fetch": 1, "git_push": 0, "polling": 0, "chair_report_critical_immediate": 1 }, "common_forbidden_maintained_12": [ "PR merge 0", "auto-merge 0", "branch 삭제 0 (★ task/task-2691-dev8 보존)", "live settings.json 변경 0", "hooks live 변경 0", "dispatch.py 변경 0", "Axis runtime 변경 0", "HARNESS_ENFORCED 전체 선언 0", "policy 승격 0", "BLOCK 확대 0", "PR #149 / PR #151 / PR #152 영역 혼합 0", "chair_authorization_id 임의 발급 코드 task 선발사 0 (★ 본 ANU 자기 정정 적용)" ], "linked_markers": [ "memory/tasks/task-2691.md (★ 원본 task md · PR #153 close 후에도 보존)", "memory/events/task-2691.done (★ dev8 라 봇 완료 marker)", "memory/events/task-2691.finish-task-latency-phase-1-result-260526.json (★ 봇 결과)", "memory/events/task-2691.merge-blocked-by-main-workspace-state.json (★ pre_push_guard blocked 원인)", "memory/events/anu_callback/task-2691-normal-completion.json (★ envelope 3 SID PASS / cron FAIL)", "memory/events/task-2691-phase-1-authorization-warn-accepted-by-chair-after-dispatch-260526.json (★ AUTHORIZATION_WARN 박제)", "memory/feedback_chair_authorization_id_must_be_chair_verbatim_for_code_tasks_260526.md (★ ANU 자기 정정 doctrine)", "memory/feedback_normal_callback_not_registered_variant_260523.md (★ 재발 사고 박제 doctrine)", "memory/tasks/task-2691+a.md (★ 후속 fresh worktree task md · 작성 진행 · 발사 대기)" ] }