{ "marker_version": "v1", "marker_type": "p1a_task_md_sha_contract_accepted_with_known_caveats_chair_closeout_260529", "recorded_at": "2026-05-29T09:25:00+09:00", "recorded_by": "ANU_chair_facing_session_p1a_closeout_packet", "source_attribution": "RECEIVED_INBOUND_THIS_SESSION (★ 회장 verbatim 최종 판정 정합 · '끝' sentinel 정합 확정 · ACCEPT_WITH_KNOWN_CAVEATS 박제 인가)", "p1a_classification": "ACCEPT_WITH_KNOWN_CAVEATS", "p1a_lineage_status": "ACCEPTED_WITH_KNOWN_CAVEATS", "p1a_full_accept_status_explicit": "★ FULL_ACCEPT 아님 (★ 회장 verbatim 명시 정합)", "p1a_reject_status_explicit": "★ REJECT 아님", "p1a_hold_for_chair_status_explicit": "★ HOLD_FOR_CHAIR 아님", "chair_verdict_7_rationale_verbatim": [ "1. task-2705+4 Maat 독립 검증 verdict가 ACCEPT_WITH_KNOWN_CAVEATS", "2. executor dev1 헤르메스와 verifier dev2 오딘이 분리됐다", "3. item 9 caller chair_authorization_id=None 결함은 task-2705+3에서 수정됐고, task-2705+4 dispatch marker에서 production runtime L4 evidence로 확인됐다", "4. task_md_sha_before=null 결함도 재발하지 않았다", "5. 18 prohibitions 위반 0", "6. mutating action 0", "7. scope-guard FAIL 25건은 task-induced blocker가 아니라 unrelated existing dirty caveat로 분류됐다" ], "chair_known_caveats_3_verbatim": [ "1. reports/task-2705.md sha drift 조사 필요", "2. task-2705+3.done 부재 + qc-result=WARN 정상화 필요", "3. Hermes 직접 구현 caveat는 self-attestation 한계로 보존" ], "maat_5_known_caveat_verbatim_from_decision_json": [ "(1) reports/task-2705.md sha drift (08e86756… ≠ d3c1b10f… · 본 task-2705+3 commit 무관 · parent lineage 별도 조사 위임)", "(2) scope-guard FAIL 25 = main..HEAD misfire (ANU STEP 1 A 분류 25/25 verifier 재현 정합 · blocker 아님)", "(3) Hermes 직접 패치 가능성 (P1-C §4 caveat 박제 정합 · FORBIDDEN 표현 사용 0)", "(4) task-2705+3.done 부재 + qc-result=WARN (escalate 분기)", "(5) verifier 모델 선언 (sonnet 또는 opus 선택 영역 caveat)" ], "chair_closeout_processing_7_verbatim": [ "1. P1-A accepted marker 작성 (★ 본 마커)", "2. 분류는 ACCEPT_WITH_KNOWN_CAVEATS", "3. task-2705 VALID_HOLD lineage 보존", "4. task-2705+1 bootstrap recovery lineage 보존", "5. task-2705+2 Maat 검증 lineage 보존", "6. task-2705+3 item 9 fix lineage 보존", "7. task-2705+4 independent verification lineage 보존" ], "lineage_preservation_verification": { "task_2705_status": "VALID_HOLD_PRESERVED (★ ACCEPT 변경 0 · lineage 산출물 sha 모두 unchanged)", "task_2705plus1_lineage": "BOOTSTRAP_RECOVERY_PRESERVED", "task_2705plus2_lineage": "MAAT_VERIFICATION_PRESERVED", "task_2705plus3_lineage": "ITEM_9_FIX_PRESERVED", "task_2705plus4_lineage": "INDEPENDENT_VERIFICATION_PRESERVED", "lineage_rewrite_count": 0 }, "chair_followup_directive_verbatim": [ "reports/task-2705.md sha drift는 read-only 조사 후보로 보존", "task-2705+3.done 부재 + qc-result=WARN은 closeout normalization 후보로 보존", "둘 다 지금 자동 구현하지 마라", "P1-B/P1-C 설계 초안은 효력 유지", "P1-B/P1-C 구현은 자동 발의하지 마라" ], "chair_6_prohibitions_continued_verbatim": [ "finish-task.sh 실행 금지", ".done 수동 생성 금지", "GitHub write 금지", "PR/branch push/merge 금지", "task-2706/2707 자동 발의 금지", "FULL_ACCEPT 단정 금지" ], "chair_current_final_state_verbatim": { "task_2703": "accepted", "task_2704": "accepted", "p1a_task_md_sha_contract": "accepted with known caveats", "p1b_finish_task_profile_contract": "design draft completed", "p1c_actor_attribution_contract": "design draft completed", "automatic_implementation_dispatch": "NO", "anu_awaiting_state": "Awaiting chair direction" }, "maat_decision_json_verbatim_verification_summary": { "decision_json_path": "memory/events/task-2705+4.decision.json", "decision_json_size_bytes": 13566, "final_classification": "ACCEPT_WITH_KNOWN_CAVEATS", "7_scope_evaluation_summary": { "item_1_12_baseline_plus_item_9_fix": "PASS [L4+]", "item_2_item_9_fix_helper_plus_2_callers": "PASS [L4+] (★ end-to-end byte-equal proof)", "item_3_9_closeout_criteria": "PASS [L4]", "item_4_replay_fixtures_schema": "PASS [L4]", "item_5_regression_pytest_readonly": "PASS [L4]", "item_6_dispatch_marker": "PASS [L4]", "item_7_chair_authorization_id_propagation": "PASS [L4+] (★ task-2705+4 production marker byte-equal)" }, "18_prohibitions_violation_count": 0, "executor_verifier_separation_verified": "dev1 헤르메스 (executor) ≠ dev2 오딘 (verifier)" }, "anu_self_attestation_per_p1c_doctrine": { "anu_role_in_p1a_closeout": "collector (★ Maat 결과 회수 + 회장 최종 판정 박제 · 자체 분류 결정 0)", "evidence_level_anu_provided": "L4 (★ STEP 0 dispatch marker read + STEP 1 sha cross-verify + STEP 2 production runtime evidence)", "anu_self_full_accept_judgment_count": 0, "anu_doctrine_compliance_evidence_only": "★ Maat decision.json verbatim 인용 · 봇 self-report 'FULL_ACCEPT 권고' 인용 0 · 회장 verbatim '자동 승격 금지' 정합 · 'evidence만 따라간다' doctrine 정합" }, "anu_mutating_action_count": 0, "anu_forbidden_action_count": 0, "anu_self_full_accept_judgment_count": 0, "anu_automatic_implementation_dispatch_count": 0, "linked_markers": [ "memory/events/task-2705+4.decision.json (★ Maat authoritative verdict)", "memory/reports/task-2705+4.md (★ Maat report)", "memory/events/task-2705+3.dispatched-20260528.json (★ pre-fix dispatch marker · task_md_sha_before non-null)", "memory/events/task-2705+4.dispatched-20260528.json (★ post-fix dispatch marker · chair_authorization_id actual value)", "memory/events/anu_step_0_task_2705plus3_artifacts_recovery_260529.json", "memory/events/anu_step_1_scope_guard_25_classification_260529.json", "memory/events/anu_step_2_task_2705plus4_independent_verification_dispatched_260529.json", "memory/events/anu_night_delegation_chair_directive_1of2_post_task_2705plus3_260529.json", "memory/events/anu_night_delegation_chair_directive_2of2_post_task_2705plus3_260529.json", "memory/events/task-2705plus1.provisional-accept-pending-maat-verification-260529.json (★ chair earlier verdict 정합)", "memory/specs/v36_task_md_sha_contract_design_draft_260528.md (★ P1-A 설계)", "memory/specs/v36_finish_task_profile_contract_design_draft_260529.md (★ P1-B 효력 유지)", "memory/specs/v36_actor_attribution_contract_design_draft_260529.md (★ P1-C 효력 유지)", "memory/reports/anu_night_delegation_final_report_260529.md (★ earlier night report · superseded by current closeout)" ] }