{
  "schema": "merge_queue_auto_merge_readiness.result.v1",
  "track": "Track G — MERGE_QUEUE_AND_AUTO_MERGE_READINESS_AUDIT",
  "ts_kst": "2026-05-21 04:48 KST",
  "mode": "read-only audit · dry-run · proposal-only",
  "verdict": "READY_WITH_PARTIAL — 14조건 12 WIRED + 2 PARTIAL_WIRED · Critical7 escalation 5종 결선 · 실제 머지 pilot 회장 승인 필요",
  "audit_target": [
    "utils/merge_queue_executor.py",
    "utils/post_merge_smoke_runner.py",
    "utils/bot_merge_identity.py",
    "utils/lifecycle_reconciliation_manager.py",
    "utils/automation_contracts.py"
  ],
  "10_chair_check_items_completion_report": {
    "1_auto_pr_readiness": {
      "verdict": "PARTIAL_READINESS",
      "artifact_ref": "memory/events/auto_pr_creation_readiness.result.json",
      "summary": "v3-equivalent replacement_pr_runner stub · anu_v2 era 가 실 구현. v3 callback contract chaining 별도 audit 권고."
    },
    "2_merge_queue_readiness": {
      "verdict": "READY_WITH_PARTIAL",
      "artifact_ref": "memory/events/queue_head_dry_run.json",
      "summary": "check_predecessor_merged + QueueDecision WIRED. serial_only collision detector + dependency cycle detector PARTIAL."
    },
    "3_auto_merge_14_condition_verdict": {
      "verdict": "12_WIRED_2_PARTIAL_0_NOT_WIRED",
      "artifact_ref": "memory/events/merge_gate_14_condition_matrix.json",
      "summary": "14조건 중 12 WIRED · 2 PARTIAL_WIRED (serial_only collision · reconcile evidence) · 0 NOT_WIRED · 15-regression classification 모두 wired_in_code 또는 PARTIAL"
    },
    "4_replacement_pr_readiness": {
      "verdict": "PARTIAL_READINESS",
      "artifact_ref": "memory/events/replacement_pr_dry_run_matrix.json + memory/events/replacement_pr_failure_critical7_fixture.json",
      "summary": "anu_v2/replacement_pr_runner.py (442 lines · v2 era) 실 구현 · utils/replacement_pr_runner.py (0 lines · stub) · v3-equivalent 미존재. fixture 설계 RPF1~RPF8 완료."
    },
    "5_bot_token_owner_pat_preflight": {
      "verdict": "PASS",
      "artifact_ref": "memory/events/bot_token_redacted_preflight.json",
      "summary": "ghs_ App token 인식 + OWNER_PAT_FALLBACK_BLOCKED fail-closed + redaction invariant (token value 0 노출) 모두 결선."
    },
    "6_post_merge_smoke_reconcile_readiness": {
      "verdict": "PASS_WITH_PARTIAL",
      "artifact_ref": "memory/events/post_merge_smoke_reconcile_dry_run.json",
      "summary": "POST_MERGE_SMOKE_HOOK + post_merge_smoke_runner (590 lines) + Critical7 escalation WIRED. lifecycle_reconciliation_manager evidence path contract PARTIAL."
    },
    "7_no_real_pr_merge_credential_write_evidence": {
      "verdict": "PASS",
      "summary": "본 audit 전 과정 read-only · dry-run · proposal-only. 실 merge 0 · 실 PR open 0 · branch/commit/push 0 · GitHub write 0 · credential raw exposure 0 (산출물 ledger 50 line byte-0 · git HEAD EQUAL · zombie cron 미접촉)."
    },
    "8_limited_live_pr_open_pilot_authorization": {
      "verdict": "REQUIRES_CHAIR_APPROVAL",
      "summary": "기술적 readiness = PARTIAL (v3 replacement_pr_runner 부재). 실제 PR-open pilot 은 별도 chair-authorized task 필요. 본 audit 범위 아님."
    },
    "9_limited_live_merge_pilot_authorization": {
      "verdict": "REQUIRES_CHAIR_APPROVAL",
      "summary": "기술적 readiness = 14조건 12 WIRED + 2 PARTIAL. Critical7 escalation 결선 완료. 실제 머지 pilot 은 별도 chair-authorized task 필요. 본 audit 범위 아님."
    },
    "10_chair_approval_required_items": {
      "items_requiring_chair_decision": [
        "(A) v3 replacement_pr_runner 구현 또는 anu_v2 의 v3 호환 명문화 (Track F 연계)",
        "(B) serial_only collision detector 명시 함수 + unit fixture",
        "(C) dependency cycle detector + Critical7 fixture",
        "(D) lifecycle_reconciliation_manager evidence path contract 명문화",
        "(E) limited live PR-open pilot (1~2 PR 한정, dry-run 검증 후)",
        "(F) limited live merge pilot (1~2 머지 한정, post-merge smoke verify 후)"
      ],
      "auto_progress": false,
      "all_items_chair_authorized_required": true
    }
  },
  "critical7_assessment": {
    "is_critical7": false,
    "rationale": "본 audit read-only · proposal-only · 활성 PR/merge/credential write 0 · 14조건 모두 wired 또는 partial wired 확인 · NOT_WIRED 0 · 활성 침해 없음",
    "shared_invariant_broken": false,
    "critical7_escalation_paths_wired": [
      "forbidden_path > 0 → Critical7 (FORBIDDEN_PATH_TRIGGERED)",
      "OWNER_PAT detected → FAIL_CLOSED (OWNER_PAT_FALLBACK_BLOCKED · capability_gap=True · Critical7 외 ops marker)",
      "HEAD SHA mismatch → FAIL_CLOSED (HEAD_SHA_LOCK_BROKEN)",
      "post-merge smoke FAIL → Critical7 (POST_MERGE_SMOKE_FAILED)",
      "replacement PR creation 실패 → Critical7 (REPLACEMENT_PR_CREATION_FAILED · v2 era 결선 · v3 chaining 별도)"
    ]
  },
  "summary_metrics": {
    "total_chair_check_items": 10,
    "pass_count": 2,
    "pass_with_partial_count": 2,
    "partial_readiness_count": 2,
    "requires_chair_approval_count": 3,
    "ready_with_partial_count": 1,
    "auto_progress_eligible_count": 0,
    "chair_approval_required_count": 6
  },
  "scope_invariants_preserved": [
    "read-only audit", "dry-run", "proposal-only",
    "실 merge 0", "PR open 0", "branch/commit/push 0",
    "GitHub write 0", "credential raw exposure 0",
    "Track C 미접촉", "zombie cron 미접촉",
    "CLOSED_ALL_SETTLED 산출물 byte-0",
    "self-key authoritative 0", "independent ANU collector 만 authoritative",
    "recovery watcher 중복 spawn 0", "loop-boundary review 0"
  ]
}