{ "packet_version": "v1", "packet_type": "chair_signature_packet_per_axis", "recorded_at": "2026-05-24T12:05:00+09:00", "recorded_by": "ANU_chair_facing_session", "source_attribution": "LOG_LOOKUP_OR_SCHEDULE_HISTORY_VERIFICATION", "scope_note": "이번 패킷은 실행/적용 승인 packet이 아님. Axis 1 단독 서명 준비 단계 (회장 verbatim 2026-05-24). HARNESS_ENFORCED 전체 진입 아님.", "axis_id": 1, "axis_name": "callback_authority_gate", "axis_task_id_source": "task-2646", "axis_runtime_guarded_status": "RUNTIME_GUARDED_ACCEPTED", "axis_runtime_guarded_marker_ref": "memory/events/task-2646.closeout-260524.json", "axis_finalize_commit": "09372a419757da090b5260d24d769145f433caa4", "axis_branch": "task/task-2646-dev3", "axis_staged_worktree": "/home/jay/workspace/.worktrees/task-2646-dev3", "field_01_activation_scope": { "scope_type": "AXIS_BOUNDED", "scope_description": "task-2646 helper 3종 + dispatch.py shim + 2 schemas 만 live path 반영. axis 2/3 모듈 격리 유지.", "scope_modules_in": [ "utils/callback_registration.py", "utils/callback_authority_validator.py", "utils/callback_source_cross_checker.py", "schemas/callback_authority_marker_v1.json", "schemas/callback_state_enum_v1.json", "dispatch.py (helper re-export shim 부분만)" ], "scope_modules_out": [ "task-2644+1 hooks 3 _v2 (Axis 2)", "task-2644+1 utils 4 _v2 (Axis 2)", "task-2644+1 schemas 4 _v2 (Axis 2)", "task-2643 PreToolUse hooks (Axis 3)" ] }, "field_02_activation_target_path": { "live_target_layout": "origin/main repo root + utils/ + schemas/ + dispatch.py", "staged_to_live_mapping": [ {"staged": "task/task-2646-dev3:utils/callback_registration.py", "live": "main:utils/callback_registration.py"}, {"staged": "task/task-2646-dev3:utils/callback_authority_validator.py", "live": "main:utils/callback_authority_validator.py"}, {"staged": "task/task-2646-dev3:utils/callback_source_cross_checker.py", "live": "main:utils/callback_source_cross_checker.py"}, {"staged": "task/task-2646-dev3:schemas/callback_authority_marker_v1.json", "live": "main:schemas/callback_authority_marker_v1.json"}, {"staged": "task/task-2646-dev3:schemas/callback_state_enum_v1.json", "live": "main:schemas/callback_state_enum_v1.json"}, {"staged": "task/task-2646-dev3:dispatch.py (helper shim re-export 부분만)", "live": "main:dispatch.py (helper shim re-export 부분만)"} ], "forbidden_target_paths_during_axis_1_signature": [ "/home/jay/.claude/settings.json", "/home/jay/.claude/settings.local.json", "/usr/local/bin/cokacdir", ".github/**", "hooks/**", "schemas/callback_ledger_*.json", "schemas/callback_next_action_decision_*.json", "schemas/anu_state_*.json", "schemas/callback_batch_aggregation_*.json" ] }, "field_03_chair_authorization_id_placeholder": { "field_name": "chair_authorization_id", "current_value": null, "expected_format": "CHAIR-AUTH-AXIS-1-YYYYMMDD-HHMMSS-", "issuance_method": "회장 verbatim signature only · ANU 자동 생성 절대 금지", "issuance_condition": "회장이 본 packet 14 필드 검토 후 별도 verbatim 서명으로 발급", "binding": "chair_authorization_id == AXIS_1 only · Axis 2/3에 재사용 절대 불가", "absence_behavior": "chair_authorization_id IS null → HARNESS_ENFORCED 진입 fail-closed" }, "field_04_real_cron_registration_required": { "required": true, "scope_under_signature": "Axis 1 helper가 dispatch.py + direct cron 양 경로에서 모두 호출되어 actual schedule owner key 검증을 실 cron 등록 직후 수행", "current_status": 0, "transition_trigger": "chair_authorization_id 발급 + Axis 1 live merge 완료 후 첫 dispatch cycle" }, "field_05_registration_argv_generated_expected": { "expected_value": true, "current_task_2647_value": false, "verification_method": "helper.register_callback() 호출 후 returned argv 비교 (ANU key owner 명시 + executor self-key 거부 시 argv=None fail-closed)", "evidence_path_post_signature": "executor result.json::callback_registration_helper_selftest_argv" }, "field_06_real_cron_id_fired_expected": { "expected_value": true, "current_task_2647_value": false, "verification_method": "cokacdir --cron 호출 응답 schedule_id 추출 + ANU key cron-history 조회 count>=1", "evidence_path_post_signature": "schedule_history/.log · cron-history ANU key count==1" }, "field_07_schedule_history_verification_method": { "verification_command": "ls -la /home/jay/.cokacdir/schedule_history/.log", "verification_assertion": "file size > 0 AND bot_key_verifier sha256 == ANU key sha256", "absence_disposition": "SCHEDULE_HISTORY_PENDING → 60초 wait + 재조회 1회 · 여전히 absent → CALLBACK_MISSING 후보 (단 4 source 교차 필수)", "anu_key_sha256_expected": "fccaf57b393889a44c85255afa6e54332add24a569bf7c79ec96769b9662520d (task-2644+1 81D90950 / task-2645 EBEF96C8 ANU 등록 실증)" }, "field_08_cron_history_owner_key_match_method": { "verification_command_anu": "/usr/local/bin/cokacdir --cron-history --chat 6937032012 --key c119085addb0f8b7", "verification_assertion_anu": "status:ok AND count==1", "verification_command_suspect_self": "/usr/local/bin/cokacdir --cron-history --chat 6937032012 --key ", "verification_assertion_suspect_self": "status:error (access denied · self-key NOT owner)", "mismatch_disposition": "OWNER_KEY_MISMATCH → NON_AUTHORITATIVE_SELF_COLLECTOR fail-closed" }, "field_09_result_artifact_path": { "path_template": "memory/events/.result.json (executor self-attestation) + memory/system/.callback_ledger.jsonl (ANU collector independent attestation)", "minimum_fields_required": [ "schema_version (v1 / v2)", "task_id", "callback_id", "schedule_id", "envelope_bytes_utf8", "actual_owner_key_verified (true)", "actual_owner_key_observed (ANU key)", "source_attribution (CALLBACK_COLLECTOR_PROCESSED)", "cross_check_state (OWNER_KEY_VERIFIED)", "control_plane_compliant (true)", "compliance_failures ([])", "live_infra_changes (0 또는 Axis 1 scope 명시값)", "regression_summary", "executor_commit_sha", "canonical_root (/home/jay/workspace)" ], "self_attestation_acceptance_blocked": "result.json self-attestation 만으로 acceptance 금지 — ANU collector independent attestation 교차 검증 필수" }, "field_10_ledger_row_append_condition": { "ledger_path": "memory/system/.callback_ledger.jsonl", "append_condition_all_true": [ "ANU collector independent spawn 확인", "envelope parsed + context recovered + terminal_state classified + next_action decided + branch taken (auto/chair/noop)", "source_attribution == CALLBACK_COLLECTOR_PROCESSED", "control_plane_compliant == true", "actual_owner_key_verified == true", "cross_check_state == OWNER_KEY_VERIFIED" ], "negative_condition_no_append": [ "executor self-key 등록 → no ledger row (NON_AUTHORITATIVE_SELF_COLLECTOR)", "OWNER_KEY_MISMATCH → no ledger row", "REGISTRATION_HELPER_BYPASSED → no ledger row" ] }, "field_11_live_callback_enforcement_value": { "axis_1_scope_value": 1, "axis_1_scope_meaning": "Axis 1 helper가 dispatch.py + direct cron 양 경로에서 actual owner key 검증 강제 (envelope ANU 표기만으로 PASS 금지)", "current_task_2647_value": 0, "transition_trigger": "chair_authorization_id 발급 + Axis 1 live merge + 첫 dispatch cycle helper 호출 확인", "scope_exclusion": "Axis 2/3 enforcement는 본 Axis 1 packet 범위 아님 · 별도 axis별 chair signature 필요" }, "field_12_rollback_trigger": { "L1_rollback_trigger_30sec": [ "Axis 1 helper 호출 시 unhandled exception (production crash)", "actual_owner_key 검증 false positive 발생 (ANU key를 mismatch로 잘못 표시)", "actual_owner_key 검증 false negative 발생 (self-key를 ANU로 잘못 표시)" ], "L1_rollback_action": "git revert + dispatch.py shim 비활성화 환경변수 토글", "L2_rollback_trigger_5min": [ "Axis 1 적용 후 5분 내 첫 dispatch cycle에서 ledger row 누락 또는 self-key 패턴 재발", "regression baseline 변화 (task-2646 124 test 중 1건이라도 fail)" ], "L2_rollback_action": "Axis 1 live revert + task-2646 RUNTIME_GUARDED 복귀 + ANU 회장 보고", "chair_rollback_trigger": "회장 verbatim revert signature 시 즉시 rollback (회장 권한)" }, "field_13_smoke_pass_criteria": { "smoke_test_set": [ "S1: dispatch.py path + ANU key → register_callback() 호출 → actual_owner verification PASS → real schedule_id 생성 → ledger row appended", "S2: direct cron path + ANU key + helper 사용 → 동일 결과 (fixture 8 회장 정정 적용)", "S3: dispatch.py path + executor self-key (의도적 위반) → SELF_KEY_FAIL_CLOSED + argv=None + no cron registered", "S4: direct cron path + helper 미사용 (의도적 위반) → REGISTRATION_HELPER_BYPASSED detected", "S5: envelope ANU 표기 + actual owner self-key 시뮬레이션 → OWNER_KEY_MISMATCH detected", "S6: 4 source cross-check (schedule_history present + cron-history ANU key match + envelope ANU + result.json appended) all PASS" ], "smoke_pass_threshold": "S1-S6 모두 PASS (6/6) · 1건이라도 fail 시 L1 rollback", "smoke_duration_max": "5분 (S1-S6 합산)", "regression_baseline_unchanged": "task-2646 worktree regression 124 test 그대로 PASS 유지" }, "field_14_forbidden_expressions_7_reconfirmed": [ "callback system verified", "HARNESS_ENFORCED", "real callback passed", "normal callback 발동 완료", "normal callback 수신 완료", "real cron fired", "live callback enforcement 완료" ], "current_forbidden_actions_during_packet_prep": { "live_settings_modified": 0, "live_cokacdir_modified": 0, "dispatch_py_modified": 0, "hooks_utils_schemas_live_path_modified": 0, "real_cron_registered": 0, "chair_authorization_id_generated": 0, "harness_enforced_declared": 0, "callback_system_verified_phrase_used": 0, "commit_push_pr_merge": 0 }, "completion_state": "AXIS_1_SIGNATURE_PACKET_READY", "next_action_required": "회장 verbatim per-axis signature (axis 1 단독 · chair_authorization_id 발급 시 HARNESS_ENFORCED 진입 가능) · ANU 자동 생성 절대 금지", "axis_2_packet_status": "NOT_PREPARED (회장 axis 1 signature 후 axis 2 packet 준비 단계 진입)", "axis_3_packet_status": "NOT_PREPARED", "chair_directive_ref": "회장 verbatim 2026-05-24 Axis 1 chair signature packet 준비 · 실행/적용 승인 아님" }