{
  "schema": "auto_pr_creation_readiness.result.v1",
  "track": "Track F — AUTO_PR_CREATION_READINESS_AUDIT",
  "ts_kst": "2026-05-21 04:35 KST",
  "mode": "read-only audit + proposal",
  "verdict": "PARTIAL_READINESS · v3-equivalent module 부재 · 회장 결정 필요",
  "10_chair_check_items": {
    "1_replacement_pr_runner_current_state": "PARTIAL — anu_v2/replacement_pr_runner.py (442 lines · v2 era) 가 실 구현 · utils/replacement_pr_runner.py (0 lines · stub) · v3-equivalent 미존재 · scripts/replacement_pr_dry_run_activation_{guard,harness}.py 존재 (task-2590 fifth-truncate halt)",
    "2_clean_replacement_pr_conditions": "DEFINED in v2 · v3 적용 여부 별도 audit 필요",
    "3_effective_diff_contamination_judgment": "WIRED via utils/merge_queue_executor.py:compare_effective_diff (L445)",
    "4_expected_files_exact_match_judgment": "WIRED via _normalize_file_list (L441) + compare_effective_diff",
    "5_forbidden_path_judgment": "WIRED via detect_forbidden_paths (L473)",
    "6_replacement_pr_failure_critical7": "DEFINED (v2 era) · v3 chaining 별도 audit · fixture 설계 8건 (replacement_pr_failure_critical7_fixture.json)",
    "7_same_branch_push_blocked": "ENFORCED via assert_no_forbidden_git_flags (L303)",
    "8_original_pr_preserved": "DEFINED (v2 clean replacement path)",
    "9_dry_run_result_json_capable": "YES · scripts/replacement_pr_dry_run_activation_{guard,harness}.py exit 87 fifth-truncate halt + JSON evidence",
    "10_real_pr_open_pilot_conditions": "REQUIRES_CHAIR_APPROVAL — 회장 verbatim 'PR open 금지' · 본 audit 는 dry-run + proposal-only"
  },
  "key_finding_v3_module_gap": {
    "issue": "v3 era 가 main production dispatch path 결선 완료(task-2621) · 그러나 replacement_pr_runner v3 equivalent 가 stub 상태 (utils/replacement_pr_runner.py 0 lines)",
    "implications": "task-2621 wiring 으로 production dispatch 의 callback contract 는 결선 완료지만 · replacement PR 자동 생성 경로는 v2 module 의존 · v3 era 와 호환성 미명확",
    "anu_view": "main production PR creation 자동화는 v2 module 가 실 사용 중이므로 즉시 위험 0 · 단 v3 callback contract chaining 가 PR creation path 에도 적용되어야 closure 진정",
    "remediation_proposal_for_chair": "별도 chair-authorized task — v3 replacement_pr_runner 구현 또는 anu_v2/replacement_pr_runner.py v3 호환 명문화"
  },
  "critical7_assessment": {
    "is_critical7": false,
    "rationale": "본 audit read-only · 활성 PR/merge/credential write 0 · v3 module 부재는 defense-in-depth 부재이지 활성 침해 아님",
    "shared_invariant_broken": false
  },
  "next_action_proposed_chair_decisions": [
    "(a) 현 상태 유지: anu_v2/replacement_pr_runner.py 가 실 사용 · v3 closure 표현 제한 (main dispatch path 만)",
    "(b) v3 replacement_pr_runner 구현 task 승인 (LOW-MEDIUM blast radius · v3 callback contract chaining)",
    "(c) limited live PR-open pilot 승인 (1~2 PR 한정 · 별도 chair-authorized · 본 audit 범위 아님)"
  ],
  "scope_invariants_preserved": [
    "read-only audit", "dry-run only", "proposal-only",
    "실 branch/commit/push 0", "PR open 0", "GitHub write 0", "credential raw exposure 0",
    "PR/merge/branch/main/credential write 0",
    "Track C 미접촉", "zombie cron 미접촉", "CLOSED_ALL_SETTLED 산출물 byte-0"
  ]
}