{ "marker_version": "v1", "marker_type": "anu_step_1_scope_guard_fail_25_classification_A_B_C_260529", "recorded_at": "2026-05-29T08:55:00+09:00", "recorded_by": "ANU_chair_facing_session_step_1_completion", "source_attribution": "RECEIVED_INBOUND_THIS_SESSION (★ 회장 verbatim STEP 1 분류 규칙 3 (A/B/C) 정합 · STEP 0 evidence 기반)", "chair_step_1_classification_rules_verbatim": { "A_action": "본 task 변경과 무관한 기존 dirty state → caveat", "B_action": "본 task가 유발한 FAIL → blocker", "C_action": "UNKNOWN → HOLD_FOR_CHAIR" }, "scope_violation_25_per_file_classification": [ { "path": ".claude/settings.json", "category": "A", "rationale": "task-2703 시점 dirty 잔여 (task-2703 .bak 파일 동반) · 본 task 변경 0", "evidence_source": "scope-violation.json + scope-diff.txt + git status doesn't show in task-2705+3 changes" }, { "path": ".claude/settings.json.bak.task-2703-pre-260528", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ 파일명 자체에 'task-2703-pre-260528' 박제 → task-2703 사전 backup 잔여 dirty", "evidence_source": "filename suffix self-attribution" }, { "path": "memory/plans/tasks/task-2703/checklist.md", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2703 plan 디렉토리 산출물 잔여 dirty · 본 task 와 무관", "evidence_source": "directory path self-attribution" }, { "path": "memory/plans/tasks/task-2703/context-notes.md", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2703 plan 산출물 잔여", "evidence_source": "directory path" }, { "path": "memory/plans/tasks/task-2703/plan.md", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2703 plan 산출물 잔여", "evidence_source": "directory path" }, { "path": "scripts/harness/__init__.py", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2703 v3.6 harness package init · 본 task 와 무관", "evidence_source": "task-2703 lineage module" }, { "path": "scripts/harness/v36/__init__.py", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2703 v3.6 harness submodule init", "evidence_source": "task-2703 lineage module" }, { "path": "scripts/harness/v36/closeout_marker_watcher.py", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2704 Control Plane P0 MVP 4 contract 중 1 (closeout marker watcher)", "evidence_source": "task-2704 lineage module" }, { "path": "scripts/harness/v36/guard.py", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2703 v3.6 harness guard module", "evidence_source": "task-2703 lineage module" }, { "path": "scripts/harness/v36/logger.py", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2703 v3.6 harness logger module", "evidence_source": "task-2703 lineage module" }, { "path": "scripts/harness/v36/rules.py", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2703 v3.6 harness rules module", "evidence_source": "task-2703 lineage module" }, { "path": "scripts/harness/v36/runtime_decision_logger.py", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2703 v3.6 harness runtime decision logger", "evidence_source": "task-2703 lineage module" }, { "path": "scripts/harness/v36/schema.py", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2703 v3.6 harness schema", "evidence_source": "task-2703 lineage module" }, { "path": "scripts/harness/v36/spawn_detector.py", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2704 Control Plane P0 MVP 4 contract 중 1 (spawn detector)", "evidence_source": "task-2704 lineage module" }, { "path": "scripts/harness/v36/watchdog_suppression_gate.py", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2704 Control Plane P0 MVP 4 contract 중 1 (watchdog suppression gate)", "evidence_source": "task-2704 lineage module" }, { "path": "scripts/session-watchdog.sh", "category": "A", "rationale": "★★ EVIDENCE 명시: (1) mtime 2026-05-28 16:15:25 (어제 task-2704 시점) · (2) git log 마지막 commit = d96ab6f2 [task-2704] · (3) git diff HEAD scripts/session-watchdog.sh = EMPTY (byte-identical) · (4) dispatch.py 내 session-watchdog 참조 0건 · (5) task md forbidden_paths 명시 박제 · → task-2705+3 변경 0 확정 · scope-guard 의 main..HEAD 측정 false positive (★ task-2569 'PR sub-task worktree isolation defect' 재현)", "evidence_source": "★ git diff HEAD empty + mtime + git log + grep + task md forbidden 박제 5중 교차검증" }, { "path": "tests/harness/__init__.py", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2703 tests package init", "evidence_source": "task-2703 lineage" }, { "path": "tests/harness/test_v36_closeout_watcher_contract.py", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2704 closeout marker watcher contract test", "evidence_source": "task-2704 lineage test" }, { "path": "tests/harness/test_v36_harness_hook_load.py", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2703 v3.6 harness hook load test", "evidence_source": "task-2703 lineage test" }, { "path": "tests/harness/test_v36_harness_jsonl.py", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2703 v3.6 harness jsonl test", "evidence_source": "task-2703 lineage test" }, { "path": "tests/harness/test_v36_harness_regression.py", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2703 v3.6 harness regression test", "evidence_source": "task-2703 lineage test" }, { "path": "tests/harness/test_v36_harness_rules.py", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2703 v3.6 harness rules test", "evidence_source": "task-2703 lineage test" }, { "path": "tests/harness/test_v36_integration_e2e.py", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2703 v3.6 harness integration e2e test", "evidence_source": "task-2703 lineage test" }, { "path": "tests/harness/test_v36_spawn_detector_contract.py", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2704 spawn detector contract test", "evidence_source": "task-2704 lineage test" }, { "path": "tests/harness/test_v36_watchdog_suppression_contract.py", "category": "A", "rationale": "★ task-2704 watchdog suppression gate contract test", "evidence_source": "task-2704 lineage test" } ], "classification_summary": { "A_unrelated_existing_dirty_state": 25, "B_task_induced_fail": 0, "C_unknown": 0 }, "anu_action_per_chair_rule": { "A_25_action": "★ caveat 처리 (회장 verbatim rule A) · blocker 아님 · main..HEAD scope guard misfire (task-2569 박제) · 후속: main 머지 + workspace cleanup 시 자동 해소", "B_0_action": "★ blocker 0 (task-induced FAIL 0)", "C_0_action": "★ HOLD_FOR_CHAIR 트리거 0" }, "session_watchdog_evidence_5_cross_verification_summary": { "evidence_1_mtime": "2026-05-28 16:15:25 (★ 어제 · task-2705+3 spawn 06:08:47 보다 약 14시간 이전)", "evidence_2_git_log_last_commit": "d96ab6f2 [task-2704] (★ task-2704 작업 commit)", "evidence_3_git_diff_HEAD_empty": "★ git diff HEAD scripts/session-watchdog.sh = no output (byte-identical with HEAD blob)", "evidence_4_dispatch_py_no_reference": "★ grep -n 'session-watchdog' dispatch/__init__.py = 0건 (★ 본 task 의 fix 영역과 무관)", "evidence_5_task_md_forbidden_paths_explicit": "★ memory/tasks/task-2705+3.md L27 + L82 + L136 모두 'session-watchdog.sh' forbidden 박제", "anu_conclusion": "★ 5 evidence cross-verification 정합 → task-2705+3 실제 변경 0 확정 · A 분류 (scope-guard false positive)" }, "step_1_conclusion": { "classification_complete": true, "blocker_count": 0, "caveat_count": 25, "unknown_count": 0, "hold_for_chair_triggered": false, "step_2_independent_verification_entry_authorized": true }, "anu_mutating_action_count": 0, "anu_forbidden_action_count": 0, "anu_self_full_accept_judgment_count": 0, "linked_markers": [ "memory/events/anu_step_0_task_2705plus3_artifacts_recovery_260529.json", "memory/events/task-2705+3.scope-violation.json (★ 25 source)", "memory/events/task-2705+3.scope-diff.txt (★ git diff name-only source)", "memory/events/anu_night_delegation_chair_directive_2of2_post_task_2705plus3_260529.json (★ 4 lineage 유지 doctrine)", "feedback_pr_subtask_worktree_isolation_260513.md (★ task-2569 박제 정합)" ] }