{
  "marker_version": "v1",
  "marker_type": "anu_step_0_task_2705plus3_readonly_artifacts_recovery_9_check_items_260529",
  "recorded_at": "2026-05-29T08:50:00+09:00",
  "recorded_by": "ANU_chair_facing_session_step_0_completion",
  "source_attribution": "RECEIVED_INBOUND_THIS_SESSION (★ 회장 verbatim STEP 0 9 확인 항목 정합 · read-only · evidence 만 따라가는 doctrine 정합)",

  "step_0_9_check_items_verbatim_result": {
    "check_1_dispatch_init_py_actual_change_site": {
      "verbatim_check": "dispatch/init.py 실제 변경 위치",
      "evidence_grep_result": "L254 _safe_compute_task_md_sha (★ task-2705+1 기존 helper) · L265 _safe_extract_chair_authorization_id (★ 본 task 신규 helper) · L3034 _safe_compute_task_md_sha caller 1 · L3046 chair_authorization_id=_safe_extract_chair_authorization_id(task_id) (★ 본 task fix caller 1) · L4075 _safe_compute_task_md_sha caller 2 · L4087 chair_authorization_id=_safe_extract_chair_authorization_id(task_id) (★ 본 task fix caller 2)",
      "fact_classification": "VERIFIED_BY_READ_ONLY_GREP",
      "result": "★ helper L265 신규 + caller 2 site fix L3046/L4087 박제 확인"
    },
    "check_2_l3016_l4057_caller_propagation": {
      "verbatim_check": "L3016/L4057 caller 전달 여부",
      "fact_observation": "task md 명시 L3016/L4057 → 실제 fix L3046/L4087 (★ helper L265 추가로 인한 +30 line shift)",
      "fact_classification": "LINE_SHIFTED_BUT_FIXED",
      "result": "★ caller 2 site 모두 None → _safe_extract_chair_authorization_id 호출로 교체 확인"
    },
    "check_3_chair_authorization_id_actual_propagation": {
      "verbatim_check": "chair_authorization_id 실제 전달 여부",
      "evidence_bot_self_report_L1": "report.md §11 L1 smoke: _safe_extract_chair_authorization_id('task-2705+3') → CHAIR-AUTH-TASK-2705PLUS3-V36-CHAIR-AUTH-CALLER-FIX-260529 verbatim 일치",
      "evidence_dispatch_marker_at_dispatch_time": "memory/events/task-2705+3.dispatched-20260528.json chair_authorization_id=null (★ 본 task fix 이전 발사 시점이므로 expected)",
      "fact_classification": "HELPER_L1_VERIFIED · DISPATCH_MARKER_NULL_AT_PRE_FIX_DISPATCH_EXPECTED",
      "result": "★ 본 task fix 적용 후 신규 dispatch 부터 실제 값 박제 (★ L1 helper 단독 검증 만)"
    },
    "check_4_task_md_sha_before_null_recurrence": {
      "verbatim_check": "task_md_sha_before null 재발 여부",
      "evidence_dispatch_marker": "memory/events/task-2705+3.dispatched-20260528.json task_md_sha_before=6917a4e73eb804169ade0413bfc1871d797d3bf8f0a05df8debfe1dc344ea07f (★ NULL 0)",
      "fact_classification": "VERIFIED_NULL_FREE",
      "result": "★ task-2705+1 _safe_compute_task_md_sha helper 정상 동작 보존 · null 재발 0"
    },
    "check_5_fixture_additions": {
      "verbatim_check": "fixture 추가 여부",
      "evidence_ls": "tests/harness/fixtures/v36_task_md_sha_fixture_N_replay_task_2705_plus_1.json (1232 bytes · mtime 06:14) + ..._task_2705_plus_2.json (1567 bytes · mtime 06:15)",
      "fact_classification": "VERIFIED_2_FIXTURES_ADDED",
      "result": "★ 2건 신규 fixture 확인"
    },
    "check_6_replay_fixture_existence": {
      "verbatim_check": "replay fixture 존재 여부",
      "evidence_filenames": "v36_task_md_sha_fixture_N_replay_task_2705_plus_1.json · v36_task_md_sha_fixture_N_replay_task_2705_plus_2.json",
      "fact_classification": "VERIFIED_BOTH_REPLAY_FIXTURES_PRESENT",
      "result": "★ task-2705+1 + task-2705+2 replay fixture 모두 존재"
    },
    "check_7_regression_count": {
      "verbatim_check": "regression 수량",
      "evidence_bot_self_report_L1": "report.md §7: 285/285 PASS (278/278 → 285/285 · +7 신규 regression delta · test_v36_dispatch_marker_contract.py 27→32 · TestCallerChairAuthIdPropagation 5 신규)",
      "fact_classification": "BOT_SELF_REPORT_L1_ONLY (★ ANU 자체 pytest 재현 미수행 · 회장 verbatim '자동 승격 금지' 정합으로 self-report 만 박제 · STEP 2 Maat 가 횡단 재현)",
      "result": "★ 봇 self-report 285/285 PASS + 7 delta · ANU 자체 횡단 검증 미수행"
    },
    "check_8_forbidden_write_check": {
      "verbatim_check": "forbidden write 여부",
      "bot_self_report_claim": "report.md §12 #2 'session-watchdog.sh 수정 위반 0 — git status 미포함'",
      "scope_violation_json_claim": "scope-violation.json 박제: scripts/session-watchdog.sh forbidden_paths 위반",
      "conflict_resolution_evidence": [
        "session-watchdog.sh mtime: 2026-05-28 16:15:25 (★ 어제 · task-2704 commit 시점)",
        "git log session-watchdog.sh: 마지막 commit = d96ab6f2 [task-2704]",
        "git diff HEAD scripts/session-watchdog.sh: EMPTY (★ no output · byte-identical)",
        "dispatch.py 내 session-watchdog 사용: 0건 (grep 결과)",
        "task md 본문 forbidden_paths 명시 박제 (L27 + L82 + L136)"
      ],
      "anu_conclusion": "★ session-watchdog.sh task-2705+3 변경 0 확정 · scope-violation 박제는 scope-guard 의 main..HEAD 측정 false positive (★ task-2569 박제 'PR sub-task worktree isolation defect' 재현)",
      "fact_classification": "VERIFIED_NO_FORBIDDEN_WRITE_DESPITE_SCOPE_VIOLATION_RECORD",
      "result": "★ session-watchdog.sh 실제 변경 0 · forbidden write 0 (★ scope-guard false positive 분류)"
    },
    "check_9_scope_guard_fail_25_origin": {
      "verbatim_check": "scope-guard FAIL 25건 원인",
      "evidence_scope_violation_json_classification": {
        "category_paths_미포함_scope_외": 24,
        "category_forbidden_paths_위반": 1
      },
      "origin_analysis_main_dot_dot_HEAD_misfire": "★ task-2569 박제 'main..HEAD scope guard misfire' 정확 재현 · task-2701~2705+1 의 미커밋 잔여 dirty state 가 main..HEAD diff 에 누적 포함 → 본 task-2705+3 의 변경으로 잘못 분류",
      "specific_origins_per_file": [
        ".claude/settings.json + .bak.task-2703-pre-260528 → task-2703 시점 dirty (잔여)",
        "memory/plans/tasks/task-2703/{checklist,context-notes,plan}.md → task-2703 plan dirty (잔여)",
        "scripts/harness/__init__.py + v36/{closeout_marker_watcher,guard,logger,rules,runtime_decision_logger,schema,spawn_detector,watchdog_suppression_gate}.py → task-2703/2704 lineage 모듈 (잔여)",
        "scripts/session-watchdog.sh → task-2704 commit d96ab6f2 미커밋 잔여 (★ git diff HEAD empty)",
        "tests/harness/__init__.py + test_v36_{closeout_watcher_contract,harness_hook_load,harness_jsonl,harness_regression,harness_rules,integration_e2e,spawn_detector_contract,watchdog_suppression_contract}.py → task-2703/2704 lineage 테스트 (잔여)"
      ],
      "fact_classification": "ALL_25_TRACEABLE_TO_PRIOR_TASKS_NOT_TASK_2705_PLUS_3",
      "result": "★ 25/25 모두 task-2705+3 변경과 무관한 prior task lineage 잔여 dirty state · main..HEAD scope guard misfire 잔여 누적"
    }
  },

  "additional_fact_observations": {
    "dispatch_marker_writer_l3_docstring_meta": "★ scripts/harness/v36/dispatch_marker_writer.py L3 = docstring 내 'chair_authorization_id=CHAIR-AUTH-TASK-2704-V36-CONTROL-PLANE-P0-MVP-260528' meta reference · 모듈 상수 0 · dynamic 동작 영향 0 · task-2705+1 결과 (signature L53 + propagation L88+L106+L153) 보존",
    "task_2705_plus_3_done_absence": "★ memory/events/task-2705+3.done 부재 · qc-done + escalate 존재 · 봇이 finish-task 워크플로우 진입 → scope-guard FAIL → escalate 분기 → .done 미생성 (★ task closeout 미완 상태)",
    "qc_result_warn_not_fail": "★ task-2705+3.qc-result qc_result=WARN (scope_check=WARN · claude_md_check=WARN · 그 외 PASS/SKIP)",
    "bot_self_report_FULL_ACCEPT_recommendation": "★ report.md L304-307 봇 self-report 'FULL_ACCEPT 가능 권고' → ★ 회장 verbatim 'task-2705+3 callback 내용은 사실(fact)로만 취급한다 / FULL_ACCEPT 권고는 self-report일 뿐이며 ANU는 승격하지 않는다' 정합 → ANU 자체 인용 0",
    "reports_task_2705_md_sha_drift_caveat": "★ 봇 self-report §9 + §16.3: reports/task-2705.md current sha 08e86756… ≠ task-2705+2 Maat 박제 d3c1b10f… (drift) · 봇 self-report '본 task 변경 0 · 별도 조사 위임' · ★ task-2705 lineage 보존 doctrine 정합 확인 필요"
  },

  "step_0_conclusion": {
    "9_check_items_completed": true,
    "fact_only_evidence_doctrine_compliance": true,
    "bot_self_report_full_accept_recommendation_ignored": true,
    "session_watchdog_actual_modification": false,
    "forbidden_write_observed": false,
    "scope_guard_fail_25_origin_attributed_to_prior_tasks": true,
    "step_1_entry_authorized": true
  },

  "anu_mutating_action_count": 0,
  "anu_forbidden_action_count": 0,
  "anu_self_full_accept_judgment_count": 0,
  "step_1_entry_state": "AUTHORIZED",
  "linked_markers": [
    "memory/events/task-2705+3.scope-violation.json (★ 25 violations source)",
    "memory/events/task-2705+3.scope-diff.txt (★ git diff name-only source)",
    "memory/events/task-2705+3.dispatched-20260528.json (★ task_md_sha_before fact)",
    "memory/events/task-2705+3.qc-result (★ qc WARN)",
    "memory/events/task-2705+3.escalate (★ scope_guard_violation escalation)",
    "memory/reports/task-2705+3.md (★ bot self-report)",
    "memory/events/anu_night_delegation_chair_directive_1of2_post_task_2705plus3_260529.json",
    "memory/events/anu_night_delegation_chair_directive_2of2_post_task_2705plus3_260529.json",
    "scripts/harness/v36/dispatch_marker_writer.py (★ docstring meta · 모듈 상수 0)",
    "dispatch/__init__.py (★ L265 helper + L3046/L4087 caller fix)"
  ]
}