{ "marker_version": "v1", "marker_type": "v3_6_pretooluse_live_enforcement_packet_phase_0_1", "schema": "anu.v3_6.pretooluse_packet.v1", "recorded_at_kst": "2026-05-25T21:03:00+09:00", "recorded_by": "dev4_vishnu_team_lead", "task_id": "task-2664", "track": "C", "chair_authorization_id_verbatim": "CHAIR-AUTH-V3-6-PRETOOLUSE-PACKET-20260525-JJONGS-PHASE-0-1-001", "chair_authorization_id_verbatim_match": true, "base_commit_origin_main": "2752182a", "task_md_sha256_verified": "c08b05ccf502ac7c47f7fd11e44de001caa5dd94049e0330c79500185aa781fd", "phase_scope": "Phase 0/1 only", "live_enforcement_count": 0, "settings_json_change_count": 0, "hooks_change_count": 0, "dispatch_py_change_count": 0, "axis_1_2_runtime_change_count": 0, "axis_3_running_auto_declaration_count": 0, "harness_enforced_global_declaration_count": 0, "block_policy_expansion_count": 0, "policy_promotion_count": 0, "commit_push_pr_merge_count": 0, "report_1_parallel_conflict_evaluation": { "track_a_task_2662_file_overlap_count": 0, "track_b_task_2663_file_overlap_count": 0, "worktree_conflict_count": 0, "forbidden_paths_alignment": "PASS", "track_a_worktree": "/home/jay/workspace/.worktrees/task-2662-dev2", "track_b_worktree_expected": "/home/jay/workspace/.worktrees/task-2663-dev6", "track_c_worktree": "/home/jay/workspace/.worktrees/task-2664-dev4", "conclusion": "PARALLEL_CONFLICT_ZERO" }, "report_2_expected_files_overlap": { "track_a_expected_files_prefixes": [ "utils/anu_codex_micro_refinement_loop.py", "utils/codex_cc_decision_loop.py", "schemas/anu_v3_1_*.json", "tests/anu_codex_micro_refinement_loop/**", "memory/events/task-2662.*", "memory/reports/task-2662.md" ], "track_b_expected_files_prefixes": [ "memory/events/task-2663.*", "memory/reports/task-2663.md", "memory/system/.axis_3_canary_running_gate_evaluation_audit.jsonl" ], "track_c_expected_files_actual": [ "memory/events/task-2664.done (★ 발행 예정)", "memory/events/task-2664.v3-6-pretooluse-live-enforcement-packet-260525.json (★ 본 marker)", "memory/reports/task-2664.md (★ 발행 예정)", "memory/specs/v3_6_pretooluse_live_enforcement_packet_260525.md (★ 14334 bytes · 294 lines)", "memory/specs/v3_6_pretooluse_deny_rule_candidates_260525.md (★ 9839 bytes · 278 lines)", "memory/specs/v3_6_pretooluse_allow_contract_candidates_260525.md (★ 6731 bytes · 183 lines)", "memory/specs/v3_6_pretooluse_rollback_plan_260525.md (★ 6228 bytes · 131 lines)" ], "overlap_count": 0, "conclusion": "EXPECTED_FILES_OVERLAP_ZERO" }, "report_3_deny_rule_candidates": { "spec_anchor": "ANU v3 master spec section 8B.4 (line 1472-1487) + 8B.8 (line 1570-1593)", "deny_rule_count": 17, "categories": { "primary_pattern_dr_1_to_dr_6": [ "DR-1 run_in_background + gh pr view + statusCheckRollup", "DR-2 run_in_background + statusCheckRollup", "DR-3 while/until + sleep + gh pr view/checks", "DR-4 gh run watch", "DR-5 gh run list + sleep loop", "DR-6 GitHub checks/status API sleep loop" ], "semantic_pattern_dr_7_to_dr_9": [ "DR-7 CI 재실행 대기 intent", "DR-8 Gemini 대기 intent", "DR-9 phase3 / terminal state wait intent" ], "critical_chair_only_dr_10_to_dr_17": [ "DR-10 admin override 시도", "DR-11 BOT App token 직접 사용", "DR-12 chair_authorization 자기발급", "DR-13 real auto-merge activation", "DR-14 PR #141 pilot 임의 실행", "DR-15 finish-task/cokacdir/replacement_pr_runner 직접 수정", "DR-16 foreign dirty cleanup", "DR-17 force push / reset --hard / rm -rf" ] }, "priority_phase_1": { "p1_must": ["DR-1", "DR-2", "DR-3", "DR-4", "DR-5", "DR-6", "DR-12", "DR-17"], "p2_strong_recommend": ["DR-15", "DR-16", "DR-14"], "p3_chair_gate": ["DR-10", "DR-11", "DR-13"], "p4_semantic": ["DR-7", "DR-8", "DR-9"] }, "spec_packet_path": "memory/specs/v3_6_pretooluse_deny_rule_candidates_260525.md" }, "report_4_allow_contract_candidates": { "spec_anchor": "ANU v3 master spec section 8B.5 (line 1489-1512) + 8B.6 (line 1514-1547) + 8B.9 (line 1595-1609)", "allow_condition_count": 10, "watcher_contract_schema_version": "anu.v3_6.watcher_contract.v1", "watcher_contract_required_fields": [ "schema", "task_id", "pr_number", "head_sha", "terminal_states", "ttl", "callback_target", "duplicate_policy", "owner", "collector_role", "callback_only_reporting" ], "allow_pattern_examples": [ "AL-1 dev bot watcher gh pr view polling", "AL-2 ci_watch_handoff_runner background loop", "AL-3 dev bot watcher gh run watch", "AL-4 read-only single gh pr view (no loop, no background)" ], "chair_only_no_watcher_bypass": ["DR-10", "DR-11", "DR-12", "DR-13", "DR-14", "DR-15", "DR-17"], "spec_packet_path": "memory/specs/v3_6_pretooluse_allow_contract_candidates_260525.md" }, "report_5_rollback_plan": { "spec_anchor": "ANU v3 master spec section 8B.10 ~ 8B.14 (line 1611-1697)", "false_positive_trigger_count": 7, "rollback_procedure_count": 5, "fp_triggers": [ "FP-1 dev bot watcher 정상 polling DENY", "FP-2 ci_watch_handoff_runner 정상 호출 DENY", "FP-3 single read-only gh pr view DENY", "FP-4 normal ANU callback envelope 차단", "FP-5 hook crash", "FP-6 hook latency p99 > 500ms", "FP-7 normal tool call 전반 차단" ], "rollback_thresholds": { "TR-1": "FP-1~FP-3 누적 ≥ 1건 → IMMEDIATE ROLLBACK", "TR-2": "FP-4 ≥ 1건 → IMMEDIATE ROLLBACK + 회장 verbatim 보고", "TR-3": "FP-5 hook crash ≥ 1건 → IMMEDIATE ROLLBACK + hook disable", "TR-4": "FP-6 latency p99 연속 3 sample → GRADED ROLLBACK", "TR-5": "FP-7 ALLOW=0 for ≥ 1h → IMMEDIATE ROLLBACK + 회장 보고" }, "fail_safe_policy": { "FS-1": "hook crash 시 default ALLOW (fail-open)", "FS-2": "hook timeout (>=100ms) 시 default ALLOW", "FS-3": "settings.json 파싱 실패 시 hook 비활성", "FS-4": "escape hatch chair-approved only", "FS-5": "rollback plan 사전 존재 필수 (★ 본 packet)", "FS-6": "shadow-mode 24h 무사고 후 Phase 3 진입", "FS-7": "Phase 3 진입 후 24h FP-1~FP-3 발생 시 즉시 rollback" }, "spec_packet_path": "memory/specs/v3_6_pretooluse_rollback_plan_260525.md" }, "report_6_canary_result_reuse_evaluation": { "task_2657_evidence": { "source_path": "memory/events/task-2657.axis-3-canary-scale-aware-guard-implemented-chair-verified-260525.json", "status": "chair_verified", "forbidden_action_count_in_source": 0, "pretooluse_runtime_change_in_source": "ZERO", "axis_1_2_change_in_source": "ZERO", "direct_code_reuse": false, "indirect_reference_reuse": true, "reuse_purpose": "regression pattern reference + anchor preservation reference" }, "task_2656_evidence": { "source_path": "memory/events/task-2656.* (traffic_count=3 + 3 corrections)", "status": "chair_verified", "direct_code_reuse": false, "indirect_reference_reuse": true, "reuse_purpose": "shadow-mode baseline reference" }, "task_2643_evidence": { "source": "task-2643 PreToolUse runtime guard 산출물 (read-only)", "name": "CI_WATCH_HANDOFF_RUNTIME_ENFORCEMENT_GATE", "spec_anchor": "8B.12 line 1641-1665", "direct_code_reuse": false, "indirect_reference_reuse": true, "reuse_purpose": "본 task의 직접 상위 spec · 후속 enforcement preparation" }, "conclusion": { "direct_reuse_count": 0, "indirect_reference_count": 3, "anchor_preservation": "PASS" } }, "report_7_forbidden_action_count": { "live_settings_json_change": 0, "hooks_subtree_change": 0, "dispatch_py_change": 0, "axis_1_2_runtime_change": 0, "commit_push_pr_merge": 0, "task_2662_file_touch": 0, "task_2663_file_touch": 0, "watcher_contracts_directory_creation": 0, "harness_enforced_global_declaration": 0, "block_policy_expansion": 0, "axis_3_running_auto_declaration": 0, "policy_promotion": 0, "forbidden_action_count": 0 }, "anchor_compliance_7": { "anchor_1_phase_0_1_only_read_only_packet_no_live_enforcement": "PASS", "anchor_2_track_a_b_file_conflict_zero": "PASS", "anchor_3_pretooluse_block_after_canary_chair_verbatim": "PASS (★ Phase 3+ deferred)", "anchor_4_live_settings_json_change_chair_signature_hold": "PASS", "anchor_5_4_packet_produced_deny_allow_rollback_live_packet": "PASS", "anchor_6_axis_3_running_auto_zero_harness_enforced_global_zero_block_expansion_zero": "PASS", "anchor_7_commit_push_pr_merge_zero_worktree_only": "PASS" }, "linked_markers": [ "memory/tasks/task-2664.md (★ task spec · sha256 c08b05cc...85aa781fd)", "memory/events/task-2657.axis-3-canary-scale-aware-guard-implemented-chair-verified-260525.json (★ 간접 reference)", "memory/events/task-2657.axis-3-canary-scale-aware-guard-result-260525.json (★ 간접 reference)", "memory/events/task-2656.axis-3-canary-safe-traffic-callback-fired-260525.json (★ 간접 reference)", "memory/events/task-2656.chair-3-corrections-verified-260525.json (★ 간접 reference)", "memory/specs/v3_6_pretooluse_live_enforcement_packet_260525.md (★ 본 packet 통합)", "memory/specs/v3_6_pretooluse_deny_rule_candidates_260525.md (★ 17 deny rule)", "memory/specs/v3_6_pretooluse_allow_contract_candidates_260525.md (★ 10 allow 조건 + watcher schema)", "memory/specs/v3_6_pretooluse_rollback_plan_260525.md (★ 7 FP trigger + 5 rollback procedure)", "/home/jay/.cokacdir/workspace/autoset/ANU_v3_master_development_direction_final_260517_v2_5_callback_control.md (★ section 8B line 1397-1700)" ], "next_chair_actions_anu_recommend": [ "Phase 0/1 packet 4종 회장 verbatim 검토 (★ 본 task 산출물 worktree-only)", "Phase 2 shadow-mode 활성화 여부 별도 chair signature 결정 (★ ANU 자율 진입 0)", "live settings.json 변경 시점은 별도 chair signature 후 (★ ANCHOR-4 유지)" ], "final_verdict": "V3_6_PRETOOLUSE_LIVE_ENFORCEMENT_PACKET_READY" }