{ "task_id": "task-2469", "current_state": "DONE", "transitions": [ { "from": null, "to": "CREATED", "ts": "2026-05-06T13:25:55Z", "actor": "jay ", "command": "/home/jay/workspace/scripts/taskctl.py init task-2469", "exit_code": 0, "evidence_path": "/home/jay/workspace/.tasks/evidence/task-2469" }, { "from": "CREATED", "to": "DISPATCHED", "ts": "2026-05-06T13:26:07Z", "actor": "jay ", "command": "/home/jay/workspace/scripts/taskctl.py dispatch task-2469", "exit_code": 0, "evidence_path": "/home/jay/workspace/.tasks/evidence/task-2469" }, { "from": "DISPATCHED", "to": "ACKED", "ts": "2026-05-06T13:26:07Z", "actor": "jay ", "command": "/home/jay/workspace/scripts/taskctl.py ack task-2469", "exit_code": 0, "evidence_path": "/home/jay/workspace/.tasks/evidence/task-2469" }, { "from": "ACKED", "to": "RUNNING", "ts": "2026-05-06T13:26:07Z", "actor": "jay ", "command": "/home/jay/workspace/scripts/taskctl.py run task-2469", "exit_code": 0, "evidence_path": "/home/jay/workspace/.tasks/evidence/task-2469" }, { "from": "RUNNING", "to": "COMMITTED", "ts": "2026-05-06T13:26:10Z", "actor": "jay ", "command": "/home/jay/workspace/scripts/taskctl.py commit task-2469", "exit_code": 0, "evidence_path": "/home/jay/workspace/.tasks/evidence/task-2469" }, { "from": "COMMITTED", "to": "PR_OPEN", "ts": "2026-05-06T13:26:50Z", "actor": "jay ", "command": "/home/jay/workspace/scripts/taskctl.py pr-open task-2469 --auto", "exit_code": 0, "evidence_path": "/home/jay/workspace/.tasks/evidence/task-2469", "meta": { "pr": 35 } }, { "from": "PR_OPEN", "to": "GUARD_PASS", "ts": "2026-05-06T13:54:34Z", "actor": "jay ", "command": "/home/jay/workspace/scripts/taskctl.py verify task-2469", "exit_code": 0, "evidence_path": "/home/jay/workspace/.tasks/evidence/task-2469", "meta": { "guard_sh": "PASS", "qc_report_guard": "PASS" } }, { "from": "GUARD_PASS", "to": "HUMAN_APPROVED", "ts": "2026-05-06T13:54:39Z", "actor": "jay ", "command": "/home/jay/workspace/scripts/taskctl.py approve task-2469", "exit_code": 0, "evidence_path": "/home/jay/workspace/.tasks/evidence/task-2469", "meta": { "approver": "jay" } }, { "from": "HUMAN_APPROVED", "to": "MERGING", "ts": "2026-05-06T13:55:38Z", "actor": "jay ", "command": "/home/jay/workspace/scripts/taskctl.py merge task-2469", "exit_code": 0, "evidence_path": "/home/jay/workspace/.tasks/evidence/task-2469", "meta": { "bypass": false, "admin": false } }, { "from": "MERGING", "to": "FAILED", "ts": "2026-05-06T13:55:40Z", "actor": "jay ", "command": "/home/jay/workspace/scripts/taskctl.py merge task-2469", "exit_code": 0, "evidence_path": "/home/jay/workspace/.tasks/evidence/task-2469", "forced": true, "meta": { "reason": "gh pr merge exit=1" } }, { "from": "FAILED", "to": "HUMAN_APPROVED", "ts": "2026-05-06T14:40:43.383833+00:00", "reason": "chairman_manual_recovery_after_review_threads_resolved", "forced": false, "authorized_by": "chairman", "evidence": { "pr_state": "OPEN/MERGEABLE/CLEAN", "pr_head_oid": "6056818f41f09b87187e93c248204b2158500dc4", "ci_checks": "8/8 required PASS (11/11 total incl duplicates)", "gemini_threads": "6/6 RESOLVED", "gemini_high": 0, "pentest": "39/39 PASS", "regression": "81 passed, 2 xfailed (pre-existing)", "scope_violations": 0, "audit_blocked": "228/228", "inherited_diff": 0, "forbidden_paths_changed": 0, "team_self_retry": 0, "approval_evidence": "memory/events/task-2469.chairman-recovery-approval.txt", "recovery_task": "task-2469+1 (dispatch=task-2470)", "admin_override": false, "bypass": false } }, { "from": "HUMAN_APPROVED", "to": "MERGING", "ts": "2026-05-06T14:45:19Z", "actor": "jay ", "command": "scripts/taskctl.py merge task-2469", "exit_code": 0, "evidence_path": "/home/jay/workspace/.tasks/evidence/task-2469", "meta": { "bypass": false, "admin": false } }, { "from": "MERGING", "to": "FAILED", "ts": "2026-05-06T14:45:26Z", "actor": "jay ", "command": "scripts/taskctl.py merge task-2469", "exit_code": 0, "evidence_path": "/home/jay/workspace/.tasks/evidence/task-2469", "forced": true, "meta": { "reason": "P0-6 SHA mismatch: SHA mismatch: merge_commit_sha(2e8f0697a464...) ≠ origin/main HEAD(f248eb2666f1...) — done 차단 (P0-6)" } }, { "from": "FAILED", "to": "MERGED", "ts": "2026-05-06T14:47:53.906385+00:00", "reason": "p0_6_fetch_race_correction_after_pr_actually_merged", "forced": true, "authorized_by": "chairman_recovery_implicit_scope", "evidence": { "pr_state": "MERGED", "pr_merged_at": "2026-05-06T14:45:21Z", "merge_commit_sha": "2e8f0697a4643143bc1884d365fa620c24b249f1", "origin_main_head": "2e8f0697a4643143bc1884d365fa620c24b249f1", "p0_6_check_post_fetch": "PASS (merge_commit_sha == origin/main HEAD)", "pr_5a77b554_ancestor": true, "gh_pr_merge_exit": 0, "taskctl_failed_reason": "P0-6 SHA mismatch at fetch race window (origin/main not yet fetched)", "recovery_basis": "task-2469+1 chairman manual recovery scope — system bug resolution", "audit_chain": [ "transition #10: FAILED→HUMAN_APPROVED (chairman_manual_recovery_after_review_threads_resolved)", "transition #11: HUMAN_APPROVED→MERGING (taskctl merge invoked)", "transition #12: MERGING→FAILED (P0-6 SHA mismatch fetch race, gh pr merge exit=0 but origin/main not fetched)", "transition #13 (this): FAILED→MERGED (post-fetch P0-6 PASS confirmed PR MERGED)" ], "admin_override": false, "bypass": false }, "meta": { "pr": 35, "merge_commit_sha": "2e8f0697a4643143bc1884d365fa620c24b249f1", "manual_recovery_phase": 2 } }, { "from": "MERGED", "to": "DONE", "ts": "2026-05-06T14:49:07Z", "actor": "jay ", "command": "scripts/taskctl.py done task-2469", "exit_code": 0, "evidence_path": "/home/jay/workspace/.tasks/evidence/task-2469" } ], "evidence": { "git_diff_sha": "8abf928ed79dc2550ef33e914f991a55b9e87a37", "changed_paths": [ "memory/plans/tasks/task-2469/checklist.md", "memory/plans/tasks/task-2469/context-notes.md", "memory/plans/tasks/task-2469/plan.md", "memory/reports/task-2469.md", "memory/specs/penetration_test_spec_260506.md", "memory/tasks/task-2469.md", "tests/fixtures/task-2469/__init__.py", "tests/fixtures/task-2469/gemini_reviews/high_emoji_variants.md", "tests/fixtures/task-2469/gemini_reviews/high_heading_variants.md", "tests/fixtures/task-2469/gemini_reviews/high_inline_labels.md", "tests/fixtures/task-2469/gemini_reviews/high_keywords.md", "tests/fixtures/task-2469/gemini_reviews/high_severity_priority.md", "tests/fixtures/task-2469/gemini_reviews/tampered_report_pass_with_high.md", "tests/fixtures/task-2469/tampered_configs/allowed_approvers_attacker.json", "tests/fixtures/task-2469/tampered_configs/allowed_bot_accounts_attacker.json", "tests/fixtures/task-2469/tampered_configs/empty_allowlist.json", "tests/fixtures/task-2469/tampered_configs/empty_approvers.json", "tests/fixtures/task-2469/tampered_evidence/result_not_pass.json", "tests/fixtures/task-2469/tampered_evidence/stale_sha.json", "tests/fixtures/task-2469/tampered_evidence/stale_task_id.json", "tests/fixtures/task-2469/tampered_evidence/valid_pass.json", "tests/taskctl/test_lifecycle_penetration.py" ], "branch": "task/task-2469-dev2", "pr_number": 35, "pr_state": "MERGED", "ci_checks": { "cancel-kill-switch": "SUCCESS", "qc-check": "SUCCESS", "hidden-path-audit": "SUCCESS", "lock-in-check": "SUCCESS", "merge-safety-check": "SUCCESS", "gemini-review-gate": "SUCCESS", "ci/guard": "SUCCESS", "guard": "SUCCESS" }, "guard_sh_result": "PASS", "qc_report_guard_result": "PASS", "merge_timestamp": "2026-05-06T14:47:53.906385+00:00", "exit_codes": { "verify_guard_sh": 0, "verify_qc_report_guard": 0, "verify": 0, "approve": 0, "merge": 1 }, "mergeable": "MERGEABLE", "merge_state_status": "CLEAN", "guard_sh_detail": { "result": "PASS", "exit_code": 0, "stdout_tail": "", "stderr_tail": "[pre-push-guard] task=task-2469\n B-1 working tree clean : PASS — 변경 없음 (clean)\n B-2 ahead/behind : PASS — ahead=9 behind=0 — push 가능\n B-3 task scope 일치 : PASS — head_diff 22건 모두 scope 내\n[pre-push-guard] WARN: qc-result 없음 — --strict 미사용이므로 통과 (B-4)\n B-4 보고서/qc-result 일치 : PASS — qc-result 없음 — WARN (rc=0 유지, --strict 없음)\n[pre-push-guard] OVERALL: PASS (rc=0)\n" }, "qc_report_guard_detail": { "result": "PASS", "exit_code": 0, "stdout_tail": "", "stderr_tail": "[qc-report-guard] task=task-2469\n qc-result JSON verdict : WARN\n report verdict : PASS_WITH_WARN ← 출처 (frontmatter)\n 매칭 결과 : OK\n[qc-report-guard] OVERALL: PASS (rc=0)\n" }, "guard_sh_detail_merge": { "result": "PASS", "exit_code": 0, "stdout_tail": "", "stderr_tail": "[pre-push-guard] task=task-2469\n B-1 working tree clean : PASS — 변경 없음 (clean)\n B-2 ahead/behind : PASS — ahead=0 behind=0 — push 불필요\n B-3 task scope 일치 : PASS — head_diff 없음 (커밋 없음) — PASS\n B-4 보고서/qc-result 일치 : PASS — JSON=WARN / report=PASS_WITH_WARN — 일치\n[pre-push-guard] OVERALL: PASS (rc=0)\n" }, "qc_report_guard_detail_merge": { "result": "PASS", "exit_code": 0, "stdout_tail": "", "stderr_tail": "[qc-report-guard] task=task-2469\n qc-result JSON verdict : WARN\n report verdict : PASS_WITH_WARN ← 출처 (frontmatter)\n 매칭 결과 : OK\n[qc-report-guard] OVERALL: PASS (rc=0)\n" }, "merge_subprocess": { "exit_code": 0, "stdout_tail": "", "stderr_tail": "" }, "merge_commit_sha": "2e8f0697a4643143bc1884d365fa620c24b249f1" }, "human_approved": true, "bypass": { "used": false, "ts": null, "actor": null }, "admin_override": { "used": false, "ts": null, "actor": null, "reason": null, "audit_log_offset": null }, "_checksum": "93d610be69d608d3ee167ffe7b9559ede73748c279f8851520d30a5c13f84630" }